News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lectures on Faster-Than-Light Travel and Time Travel by skissane on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:30AM (#31190430)
> I don't buy your claim that an educated (implying literate) person would not understand the idea of storage of information.

I agree they'd understand we can store information in written documents, etc. But I don't see why they'd make the leap from information can be stored somewhere to all information must be stored somewhere. The later is a modern view rather than an ancient/mediaeval one. But, absent the belief that all information must be stored somewhere, my hypothetical disembodied mind has no reason to assume its own thoughts/memories/etc must be stored somewhere.

> Keeping BBs from appearing practically everywhere in the universe turns out to strongly limit a number of features of the not-full-of-false-brains universe we appear to inhabit

I think BB arguments are dubious, because they all involve disputable philosophical assumptions (about the nature of consciousness/etc). If you subtract those philosophical assumptions, BB arguments no longer work as justifications for rejecting those physics theories which produce "too many" BBs. Also: if combining a philosophical assumption with a scientific theory produces absurdity, why treat that as an argument against the scientific theory, when instead you could use it as an argument against the philosophical assumption?

Re:Lectures on Faster-Than-Light Travel and Time Travel by raattgift on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:47PM (#31198614)
You can substitute Boltzmann pine trees or Boltzmann gold ingots for Boltzmann brains: the idea is that something of high complexity fluctuates into existence from a (vast! vaaaaassssssst!) thermal medium. The crucial point is that a small arbitrarily complex pattern repeated often is a lot more likely than a much larger pattern in which these smaller complex patterns evolve.

In physical cosmology, the Boltzmann brains issue is: how can the sky full of many galaxies (in which solar systems form) instead of many many many more complicated things (automobiles? space probes?) that were not produced by the operation of processes within galaxies? Why isn't the sky full of gazillllions of space probes with nearly zero galaxies? Instead, in practically every direction we look, we see trillions of galaxies, and (at least for now) very few space probes. (That these galaxies may end up being populated with lots and lots of space probes eventually is the point.)

We can coarsen and run into the same problem: why are stars organized in galaxies (and clusters of galaxies) rather than appearing randomly throughout the cosmos? The latter is much much much more likely in fluctuation theory.

You can substitute a sparse cold non-self-interacting and generally non-interacting gas that occasionally condenses briefly into patterns that look like a small snowman, compared to much larger and more complicated patterns (perhaps whole armies of snowmen aligned rank-and-file) if you prefer not to think too hard about intermolecular and similar forces, and want to whittle down some your objections about how thought and memory might work.

> my hypothetical disembodied mind has no reason to assume its own thoughts/memories/etc must be stored somewhere

Which is why I asked you to imagine putting the idea to your friendly disembodied mind in order to get said mind to consider that and reply with its thoughts on the matter. Having been asked, it then has a reason to ponder (admittedly not assume) that its own thoughts/memories/etc must be stored somewhere.