News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:20PM (#31181972)
> if exclude the political bend of the actions

Yes, if we exclude the thing that people are complaining about, there is no basis for complaint.

Let's suppose the federal government adopted 30 percentage point higher tax rates for everyone who registered as a Republican, donated to a Republican party committee or candidate, or voted in a Republican primary.

Now, particular tax rates are not themselves a matter of right, so by the same logic that there is no basis to complain about the political retaliation against Disney since it is not via something that is a matter of right, Republicans would have no valid basis for complaint.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by daenz on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:25PM (#31182063)
I'm not sure I understand the hypothetical. I am against members of any political party receiving unfair privileges. And I would be 100% ok with the removal of those privileges, even if it was an explicit result of that person exercising their free speech.

EDIT>> Oh I think I see now, you are comparing the introduction of a special tax hike on a group of people with removing special privileges from Disney. Those aren't the same at all.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:48PM (#31182430)
How is an adverse change in government treatment not (aside from motivation) violating a matter of right not analogous to an adverse change in government treatment not (aside from motivation) violating a matter of right in the only way at all relevant to discussion of whether the fact that the issue is not (aside from motivation) violating a matter of right makes an adverse change in government treatment permissible?
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by daenz on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:54PM (#31182527)
>adverse

That's the key. I'm arguing that "adverse" doesn't mean "not receiving special unfair treatment."

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:02PM (#31182636)
> That's the key. I'm arguing that "adverse" doesn't mean "not receiving special unfair treatment."

“Adverse change” means a change in which the resulting condition is worse for the entity involved than the status quo ante.

The justice of either the resulting state or the status quo ante is not relevant to whether the change is adverse.

There is no dispute that:

(1) Florida intends Disney to be worse off because of this change, and

(2) Florida is motivated by Disney's exercise of its First Amendment rights in making this change.

This combination is impermissible regardless of any other context, and is absolutely retaliatory regardless of any other context.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by daenz on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:06PM (#31182698)
I think we've both made very clear points, we just continue to disagree. Thanks for being civil.