News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by pstuart on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:01PM (#31181713)
I don't see people going out to defend that. It's the fact that it's naked retribution for not supporting one of their other agendas, which itself is flat out designed for political theater.
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by stuxnet on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:11PM (#31181821)
Some call it retribution, others call it reversing a privilege that should not have existed in the first place.

I find it most humorous that the ones calling it retribution would generally support this measure if it had been forced on, say, Koch Industries in a red district of a purple state.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:36PM (#31182237)
> Some call it retribution, others call it reversing a privilege that should not have existed in the first place.

Sure. But rolling back those privileges within an act of overt political revenge - that insures it becomes yet another expensive, taxpayer funded bench-slap.

Two of FL's legal money-drains - see FL mention: https://www.project-disco.org/competition/033122-despite-war...

and there's this: https://www.orlandosentinel.com/opinion/scott-maxwell-commen...

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by stuxnet on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:20PM (#31182902)
Thanks for the links! I agree with you that it's almost certainly related to recent events and probably not the best course of action to save taxpayer money in the short term.

To restate my position - I don't believe that Disney (or any other corporation) should ever have the ability to levy taxes in their own special district as that is explicitly a function of government.

Instances of political revenge, especially in this day and age, are not rare or limited to one side of the political spectrum. I oppose any attempts to target groups of non-affiliated people (by race, sexual orientation, etc), but can't be too upset when the casualty is a mega corp like Disney.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by colburnmh on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:05PM (#31198211)
So, your position is that it's OK if it's political revenge against Disney, because they make lots of money?

You realize that is a very slippery slope, right? The first amendment confers free speech as a right regardless of your financial status. If you start to erode that right, and say "if you are 'rich' it's OK if your rights are trampled," then the subjective definition of "rich" will just be adjusted to match the person currently in the crosshairs, until one day, the person in the crosshairs is you.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by pstuart on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:33PM (#31182184)
So what was the motivation for this then?

Some of us are ok with pointing out issues regardless of "whose side" is involved. It would be nice if there were more of us like that.

edit: @stuxnet I can't reply to your reply so I'll amend here:

I'm not a Disney fan either but that's not the concern being addressed -- it's the "reasoning" behind it and the fact that it fits into a pattern of harassments and intimidation of all who do not support them.

Punishing others as political theater is dangerous territory and it only seems to be accelerating. Public officials/applicants are advocating for death to all who oppose them. If that doesn't bother you because you're on the right team then I encourage you to revisit that and examine how that might not be good for society.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by stuxnet on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:56PM (#31182557)
I'm not particularly a fan of Disney or the Florida legislature so I totally agree with your second point.

The point I was trying to make is that regardless of the recent motivations, the end result is that a mega corporation is stripped of privileges that they shouldn't have had in the first place. I would support that in this case and also the other fictional case I presented with Koch Industries.

So I guess the point of contention is in the motivation, but that doesn't matter to me as long as the end result is the same.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by colburnmh on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:15PM (#31198316)
It's your interpretation that Disney should never have had those rights. The state of Florida clearly strongly disagrees with you, given that they have granted the same/similar rights to thousands of entities over more than 200 years (yes, before Florida was even a state). 1800 different active entities currently have special district rights in Florida.

I think debating whether special districts should be allowed at all would be a good discussion to have, but it is completely separate from whether what the government did in passing SB-4C is a violation of Disney's (and possibly the Orange and Osceola county taxpayers') first amendment rights.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by _-david-_ on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:29PM (#31182120)
I don't think it was retribution.

Most people had no clue Disney had special privileges. Due to the extra eyes on Disney because of their opposition to the Parental Rights in Education bill and the arrest of some Disney employees on human trafficking charges people learned about the special privileges. Once people learned about the special privileges the lawmakers decided to remove them due to the public support of doing it. Doing what the people want is what politicians are supposed to do.

I think there would have been calls to remove the special privileges regardless of Disney's opposition to the bill.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:42PM (#31182309)
> I don't think it was retribution.

It's retribution.

Desantis’ lap dog Rep. Randy Fine says that Disney must be punished for not behaving property. "It’s time for them to remember that we are not CA. They are a CA company. And we are not interested in their CA values here in this state.

But here’s the issue, when my 14-year-old or my 10-year-old ask for special privileges? They behave! And they don’t expect those special privileges if they act like jerks. So Disney is learning that they are a guest in this state."

ref: https://www.techdirt.com/2022/04/22/florida-republican-govt-...

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by denton-scratch on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:38PM (#31183190)
Ooh, OK. That looks like a smoking gun; a legislator saying on the record that they voted with the intention to punish. Are "their CA values" speech?
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by _-david-_ on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @12:49PM (#31182440)
They didn't say it was due to their opposition to this bill but for misbehaving. Disney has been doing quite a bit of things that Floridians don't like. Bringing a young kid on ABC (owned by Disney) to promote transgenderism in prepubescent kids for example. This has been brewing for a long time.

Like I said, the bill was the catalyst of this, but not really the reason.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by colburnmh on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:25PM (#31198408)
Just the characterization of Disney's opposition to the "Parental Rights in Education" bill as "misbehaving", is telling. Voicing you opposition of government legislation is a right enshrined in the first amendment. It's not "misbehaving"--it's exercising a constitutional right.

What happens if the Florida legislature flipped Blue next election, and started passing legislation against right-leaning entities for "misbehaving" by voicing opposition to more liberal social policies?

What happens if the legislature decides to use eminent domain to repossess your house because they disagree with a Tweet you made?

Hopefully, you can see how these actions are pernicious attacks on the first amendment.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:12PM (#31182771)
> They didn't say it was due to their opposition to this bill but for misbehaving.

Not precisely. They clarified Disney's misbehavior was having "CA Values" in FL.

It’s time for them to remember that we are not CA. They are a CA company. And we are not interested in their CA values here in this state.

This and other "We're going after Disney" statements were made days/hours after Disney voiced it's objections to the Don't Say Gay bill. The legislators' messaging is fairly unambiguous here.

The implication that dissolving RCIC was already destined to happen at this time, that seems disingenuous given that the Governor's staff had - only last year - carved out Disney from FL's unconstitutional SM law.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by _-david-_ on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @01:45PM (#31183303)
I think it was the opposition to the Parental Rights bill that allowed for the widespread support of removing the special privileges. I think that many in Florida including the some representatives wanted to remove the privileges before but couldn't find any reason that was popular enough. Things like promoting prepubescent trans children on TV never made the headlines so they couldn't run on that. When Disney opposed a bill whose stated goal is to protect children, which the majority of people in Florida regardless of political party support, while at the same time Disney had multiple employees arrested for human trafficking it opened an opportunity. The politicians took it and removed the privileges.

I don't believe it would have happened at this time if Disney had not opposed the Parental Rights bill. Like I said above I believe it opened the opportunity up to do it. If Disney hadn't opposed this bill the next time they did something unpopular with the average Floridian they would have lost their special privileges.

I think there is a long list of things that Disney has been supporting for years that the average Floridian opposes and considers CA values. I think promoting trans kids and putting warnings on old movies are good examples.

I think the politicians who gave Disney an exception wanted to use Disney, but I don't think they actually supported Disney. Disney's support for various woke thing was widely known by conservatives. I doubt those involved with the exception supported Disney back then. They just didn't have the opportunity to implement what they wanted.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by colburnmh on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:43PM (#31198584)
> I think it was the opposition to the Parental Rights bill that allowed for the widespread support of removing the special privileges.

Except that it wasn't "removing special privileges" from anyone but Disney:

* What about the special privileges that 1800+ other entities have under Florida's special district laws? Why are they not also being discussed for dissolution?

* Why was the bill introduced, passed with no debate in either house, and signed into law in a 4 day period and in a special session that was not even called for the purpose of debating special districts (it was amended by DeSantis to specifically allow this bill to be passed)?

* Why is the bill structured to force Disney to transition all of the RCID infrastructure and services to Orange and Osceola counties before dissolution on July 1, 2023, but Disney cannot petition for the special district to be re-established until on or after July 1, 2023? That provision means Disney has to transfer all infrastructure/services to the county, petition the government to re-establish the special district, then transition all the infrastructure/services back to the RCID if the petition is granted. All the costs of that mandated, obviously useless double-transition, will be borne by both Disney and the counties taxpayers, and will likely be in 10s-100s of millions of dollars, each.

PS: Yes, the final bill SB-4C dissolves a total of six special districts, mostly to obscure the fact that this was specifically targeting Disney, but none of the other five will suffer even a tiny fraction of the same financial or ongoing business impacts that Disney and Orange and Osceola counties and their taxpayers will.

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by pstuart on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @02:02PM (#31183527)
> promoting trans kids

I had too search for it. I found a PSA that I think you might be referring to: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/06/disney-networks-among-outlet...

Do you take issue with its contents?

Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by _-david-_ on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @03:09PM (#31184408)
That is not what I am referring to. I should have been clear. I was primarily talking about Desmond Napoles, but there are other cases that ABC has been involved with as well. This sort of thing has been going on for years.
Re:Disney tells investors state can’t dissolve special distr... by colburnmh on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:18PM (#31198340)
Where are those calls prior to Disney's opposition to the "Parentel Rights in Education" bill? Special districts are widely used in Florida. It's not like it's some great secret.