Re:Lectures on Faster-Than-Light Travel and Time Travel
by tsimionescu on Wednesday April 27, 2022 @03:20AM
(#31177205)
> The measurement problem of QM arises only when one tries to define an interaction of a classical measurement device and a quantum system.
The measurement problem arises when one tries to use QM to predict empirical observations. The concept is fundamental to QM as a physical theory - remove it, and QM can no longer be said to agree with experimental observations (in fact, it contradicts them), so it can no longer be verified to be a physical theory.
> But everything is quantum at the end. So there are no classical devices.
This remains a supposition. It is possible that the classical world is indeed an emergent phenomenon, as in the many-worlds interpretation for example, but we don't yet have a full, experimentally verifiable account of how that would work. Decoherence has shed some light on aspects of the problem, but it is not enough (it does not account for the choice of observable to measure, the preferred basis problem).
> Asymmetry would imply that one could distinguish the past from future, but it would not explain why what we perceived as the past is the past and not the future.
Yes, that is a good point. However, moving from the future to the past in SR requires something that can move faster than light (faster than c). Such a particle is in principle possible, but it has negative energy. As such, if such a particle could actually exist, QM would predict that pairs of this particle and regular particles would form all the time in the void, and thus the universe would quickly become pure chaos (this prediction comes from the observation that energy is conserved if in a region of 0 energy you create a particle with energy E and one with energy -E).
So, if we can establish that the future and the past are distinguishable, then relativistic quantum mechanics requires that movement is only possible from the past to the future, and this should give us an arrow of time even at the microscopic level.
The measurement problem arises when one tries to use QM to predict empirical observations. The concept is fundamental to QM as a physical theory - remove it, and QM can no longer be said to agree with experimental observations (in fact, it contradicts them), so it can no longer be verified to be a physical theory.
> But everything is quantum at the end. So there are no classical devices.
This remains a supposition. It is possible that the classical world is indeed an emergent phenomenon, as in the many-worlds interpretation for example, but we don't yet have a full, experimentally verifiable account of how that would work. Decoherence has shed some light on aspects of the problem, but it is not enough (it does not account for the choice of observable to measure, the preferred basis problem).
> Asymmetry would imply that one could distinguish the past from future, but it would not explain why what we perceived as the past is the past and not the future.
Yes, that is a good point. However, moving from the future to the past in SR requires something that can move faster than light (faster than c). Such a particle is in principle possible, but it has negative energy. As such, if such a particle could actually exist, QM would predict that pairs of this particle and regular particles would form all the time in the void, and thus the universe would quickly become pure chaos (this prediction comes from the observation that energy is conserved if in a region of 0 energy you create a particle with energy E and one with energy -E).
So, if we can establish that the future and the past are distinguishable, then relativistic quantum mechanics requires that movement is only possible from the past to the future, and this should give us an arrow of time even at the microscopic level.