Re:Lectures on Faster-Than-Light Travel and Time Travel
by tsimionescu on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @05:39PM
(#31173517)
I have no problem with the snipe, I was indeed confused on some items (particularly, I stupidly claimed that different observers can disagree on the order of events that are part of some event's light cone).
You're right of course about the missing ds or deltas in the Minkowski metric, and there's also a missing square, since that is the square of the 4-distance, not the 4-distance.
However, on the basic point that Minkowski spacetime is different from a Cartesian 4-dimensional space, and thus time can be seen as fundamentally different in nature than the space coordinates, in not sure why you claim I am mistaken. Maybe the specific wording I chose, "separate", was the issue?
Time and space are of course tied together in SR&GR, whereas they are more firmly separated in Newtonian mechanics. But "separate" can also mean "different", and I think it is corect to say they are still different things even in GR, though they are tied to each other.
You're right of course about the missing ds or deltas in the Minkowski metric, and there's also a missing square, since that is the square of the 4-distance, not the 4-distance.
However, on the basic point that Minkowski spacetime is different from a Cartesian 4-dimensional space, and thus time can be seen as fundamentally different in nature than the space coordinates, in not sure why you claim I am mistaken. Maybe the specific wording I chose, "separate", was the issue?
Time and space are of course tied together in SR&GR, whereas they are more firmly separated in Newtonian mechanics. But "separate" can also mean "different", and I think it is corect to say they are still different things even in GR, though they are tied to each other.