Re:There is only one Cloud Icon in the Entire Universe
by jinushaun on Sunday October 16, 2011 @08:42AM
(#3117211)
I think even without having seen those logos, I would draw a cloud the same way: one big bump with a smaller bump on the side. I wouldn't go as far as referencing the golden ratio, but something about it feels "right." It's hard to explain unless you're also artistically inclined.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:There is only one Cloud Icon in the Entire Universe
by stonemetal on Sunday October 16, 2011 @11:02AM
(#3117432)
True but if you consider that all those icons come from the Apple store, most(if not all) were created after Apple used it for the mobile me icon. Following the Golden ratio doesn't explain it all, why aren't any of the icons symmetric(another one of those things people find beautiful like the golden ratio), why do all the icons have flat bottoms. There is more similarity than can be explained by the golden ratio.
Re:There is only one Cloud Icon in the Entire Universe
by 5hoom on Sunday October 16, 2011 @06:30PM
(#3118509)
Symmetry would probably make it hard to identify as a cloud. It would look like an inkblot-test picture.
The flat bottoms however, hmm…
[Edit] Well, wavephorm has a good answer to that elsewhere in the discussion: Because clouds are flat on the bottom and bumpy on top. ;)
Re:There is only one Cloud Icon in the Entire Universe
by eliasmacpherson on Sunday October 16, 2011 @11:28AM
(#3117483)
It's probably from the clouds used in weather forecasts, I can remember seeing this cloud 'design' going back to the late eighties.
Re:There is only one Cloud Icon in the Entire Universe
by 5hoom on Sunday October 16, 2011 @06:31PM
(#3118510)
This is true. The first thing I would think of would be a round 'cartoony' cloud like the ones shown.
You could do a more stretched or jagged looking cloud, but it could easily end up implying 'danger' or 'bad-weather'.
The rounded happy-cloud does seem the obvious first choice.