Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by Manuel_D on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:52PM
(#31169835)
Sure. But things like evolution, the big bang theory, and the formation of the solar system is a bit more sound than Rangi and Papa creating the world. Maori culture absolutely should be taught - in social studies classes, just like how we teach about Zeus and Osiris but draw a distinction between that and science.
Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by photochemsyn on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:30PM
(#31170427)
I really liked how Feynman discussed Mayan astronomy - they had a higly accurate calendar based on detailed astronomical observations, which made pretty accurate predictions - but they didn't have a very good model, i.e. the notions of planets in space orbiting the sun had nothing to do with their system. Now, was the Mayan calendar a scientific system or not? It had observations and predictions, after all.
It's entirely possible the some of the scientific models we now use are similar in nature to the Mayan calendar, even though they're based on accurate observations and make good predictions. It's an interesting concept, in any case.
Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by Manuel_D on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:38PM
(#31170525)
Right, plenty of early calendar systems formed the basis of early astronomy. It's fair to call that science.
But calling mythological creation stories science is not. Rangi and Papa are no more scientific than Cronus and Gaia. It's literally teaching creationism, just a different creation story than the Judeo-Christian one.
Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by zozbot234 on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:04PM
(#31170903)
Early astronomy was indistinguishable from astrology. Is that "science" too?
Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by Manuel_D on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:14PM
(#31171036)
The astronomical parts of that, yes. Say some historical scholar plotted the movements of the planets and concluded that people born under a certain constellation share a characteristic because of a supernatural aspect of the planet. The former - the tracking of celestial objects - is science, the latter part rooted in superstition is not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C4%81tauranga_M%C4%81ori#Dis...
Other aspects of the issue seem more like social choice - i.e. 'free-market economic theory' as practiced today is no more 'scientific' or 'mathematically sound' than Maori Matauranga social notions about how best to organize societies and 'pursue happiness' - perhaps they have different notions of what happiness means, is all.