News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by steve_g on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:54PM (#31157563)
My initial thought was that I didn't like that prescription. But I'd like to know _why_ the author thinks "joke less, laugh less" would help with divisiveness.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by dfxm12 on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:12PM (#31157825)
I'm not the author, but I was in a Teams chat with my manager and another guy (that we needed help from). The other says something, my manager posts a huge frowny face with no context and the other guy kinda disengaged from the conversation. Privately, I reached out to both. I told my manager their reaction was harsh. My manager said "I was joking, they knew I was joking". The other guy said "I worked hard on that, the negative reaction was completely unwarranted." In the end, I was able to smooth things over, but I wonder if we could've finished up sooner or if my manager cashed in a little too much good will because of a dumb emoji.

I guess the point is, it's not always clear what is a joke (or by extension, what, or who, is being laughed at).

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by electric_mayhem on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:58PM (#31157630)
Humor isn’t universal.

Had a coworker who would routinely make jokes assuming alignment with his own extremist political preferences and it was uncomfortable like whoa.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by jimmyjazz14 on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:12PM (#31157838)
I've been able to laugh and joke around with people I work with from all over the globe (literally), its one of the most valuable tools I have found to create a sense of ease of friendliness in the workplace. Self deprecating humor is also a great way to show that you don't take yourself to serious and to ease tensions when divisiveness may arise. I think the better suggestion is to not talk about politics and don't gossip.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by tetraca on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:09PM (#31157789)
In that case, I don't think the idea of joking was the problem so much as shoving politics into the workplace.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by vkou on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:16PM (#31157891)
The problem is that what you think is funny may be uncomfortable to a other people, and for some reason, it's always the funny guy who thinks that the onus is on everyone else to shift their behavior to accommodate his comfort.

It gets worse when half the team is laughing, and the other half are praying for you to be struck dumb already.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by lijogdfljk on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:38PM (#31158169)
Man it just sounds like such a miserable drone workplace to have no one laughing.

Giving up on laughter seems a "baby with the bathwater" approach to inclusiveness. I suppose being miserable is rather inclusive though :/

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by tetraca on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:13PM (#31158619)
It's really not that hard to keep your forms of merriment clean and appropriate, if you are a generally good-natured person that likes who you work with and wants to make them laugh.

That said, there are certainly people that can only perform humor as a zero-sum game. But in my experience they are also generally the kind of people that subject their coworkers to uncomfortable conversations in a myriad of other ways.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by throwaway0a5e on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:53PM (#31158374)
Or not being able to pivot when your jokes aren't well received.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by micromacrofoot on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:04PM (#31157714)
If you can't tell a joke without insulting someone, the fault isn't with humor, it's with you.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by swatcoder on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:34PM (#31158111)
It’s not just about insults.

If you come into a tight culture of people who will riff all day on harmless puns, or crack references to old Jersey Shore dramas, or whatever, it can be acutely alienating.

I wouldn’t personally want to work in a place so sterile, but I also feel confident in my ability to float around and either find a lively culture that suits me or work my way into a culture that once felt alienating.

But not everybody feels so confident in that, and sterile results-focused work communities get the opportunity to have these people thrive.

That sounds good for those people and for those organizations.

As long as the whole job market isn’t made to look that way, I’m not sure there’s a big critique to make.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by drewcoo on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:48PM (#31158295)
> a tight culture of people . . . can be acutely alienating

Exactly. And people are saying "don't rob us of our culture." That ain't woke.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by bachmeier on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:53PM (#31159099)
Or you could spend your energy doing your job rather than figuring out which jokes are safe.

[Tells joke about Bob] [No laughter] [Bob is on the conference call]

[Tells political joke] [Others think you're stupid but don't say anything]

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by throwaway0a5e on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:55PM (#31158403)
Disagree. Insult everyone approximately equally is a much more tractable goal and delivers far better results.

There's a line to be walked but it's not hard, it just takes practice.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by munk-a on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:34PM (#31158114)
I think that most people can't - and that'd make avoiding jokes a good rule for the majority to follow.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by hprotagonist on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:59PM (#31157644)
dad joke time.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by gonzo41 on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:35PM (#31158131)
It seems like the advice is more like "Be the cog you are".
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by narag on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:48PM (#31158298)
But I'd like to know _why_ the author thinks "joke less, laugh less" would help with divisiveness.

If avoiding "divisiveness" needs killing jokes and laugh, welcome divisiveness, whatever it is.

In my mind, I translate "divisive" as "doesn't think like I do" so it makes total sense to like it.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by allannienhuis on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:22PM (#31158734)
doesn't 'divisive' generally mean to divide, as in separate into opposing factions? What you're describing seems more like 'diversity', which is pretty different I think.
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by narag on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:32PM (#31158850)
It's Newspeak.

This particular manipulation of language consists in the confusion of cause and effect.

Diversity of opinions exists. It's good and it's accepted to be good, even if it makes feel some people bad sometimes. Freedom of speech requires effort to accept we're different. To make it sound bad, you need to create a frame where everybody agrees on everything until some evil "divisive" person creates division.

That's false.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by micromacrofoot on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:02PM (#31157681)
Since it's included with "gossip" I assume it's to avoid insulting people (intentionally or accidentally), but suggesting that humor is off limits entirely is an outrageous over-correction.

Ironically I think the author has included an incredibly divisive opinion in a post about being less divisive, and has therefore dissolved any authority on the matter.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by DoreenMichele on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:10PM (#31157802)
It didn't suggest any such thing though. It said joke and laugh less. It didn't forbid them.

Humor that doesn't offend can be hard to pull off. If you crack jokes regularly, odds are high some of them will be offensive.

Most people are quick to assume you are laughing at them, not with them. So if you are laughing a lot at work, odds are good someone will take that as mocking, as disrespect, as you not being adequately serious about the job.

If you are careful with humor, you can do good things with it. People who joke habitually are probably not being careful with it.

Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by jimmyjazz14 on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:15PM (#31157875)
Sounds like maybe you need some new coworkers because where I work we laugh and joke around all the time and nobody ever gets offended (or offers offense).
Re:Simple Ways to Be Less Divisive (2021) by tyrfing on Monday April 25, 2022 @01:23PM (#31157992)
Most jokes build on shared context, therefore jokes are inherently exclusionary and discriminatory by excluding people without the shared context. Avoiding most humor is thus a good idea.