News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by jsnk on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:23AM (#3114946)
How do you tell that iPhone 4S has more accurate colors without actually seeing the real objects?
Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by sjs on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:54AM (#3115026)
Maybe he has the same keyboard and has seen a can of Diet Pepsi before. It's not hard to imagine that being true.

I think that the 4S shot is too red/yellow compared to the Galaxy II. This sort of comparison is pretty subjective though.

(aside for evanwalsh: for the record I hate my Nexus One and have a 4S on the way)

Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by stewbrew on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:29PM (#3115262)
Does he also have the same light/lamp/bulb?

Without making sure parameters & the software used were the same, such a casual comparison doesn't seems too useful to me.

Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by drzaiusapelord on Saturday October 15, 2011 @03:48PM (#3115602)
There's no absolute color. Color is what we humans see when photos bounce off objects. The spectrum of light bouncing off isn't absolute. You have no idea what those objects really look like. The lighting in the room matters. I have both CFL and old fashioned bulbs in my house. If I took a photo of something you knew in both rooms you'd be unable to tell me which is more accurate, because only I know the lighting in my rooms and you don't.

You may be able to say "this photo looks right" but that's pretty darn subjective. Turns out we humans are kinda useless for tests like these. Past a few megapixels this stuff really doesn't matter because things like focus, lenses, and lighting are so much more important than resolution. The photos are "sharp" enough and none of these phones support mounting lenses or lights on anything. So its kind of arbitrary. Unless one of these phones has an especially shitty lens or focus or bad software, they'll probably just look mostly the same. I consider these long solved issues and don't expect much difference.

Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by evanwalsh on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:25AM (#3114953)
He probably owns an iPhone 4S.
Re:Robert Scoble's Galaxy S II vs iPhone 4S camera test by arkitaip on Saturday October 15, 2011 @01:17PM (#3115237)
I have enough image editing experience that I can see this fairly quickly. Also, I've seen a couple of desks, keyboards and books in my days...