News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by arinlen on Saturday April 23, 2022 @06:04PM (#31139083)
> Boss wants to change our iOS game icon. Changing icon requires a new build. A new build requires iPhone X support. iPhone X build target requires Xcode 9. Xcode 9 requires macOS 10.12. OS update breaks old Unity3D. Upgrading Unity breaks build.

* The iPhone X was released on 2018.

* Xcode 9.0 was released on 2017, and 9.4.1 (last release) on 2018.

* macOS 10.12 was released on 2016.

I'm sorry to say, but this sort of setup does not reflect well on anyone working on the project. Apple's call out should be considered a wakeup call.

Also, doesn't Xcode 9 only support iOS releases up to iOS 11? The global market of all iOS versions lower than iOS 11 should lie in the lower single digits.

Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by maccard on Saturday April 23, 2022 @06:57PM (#31139486)
The problem here is unity (which, by the way is one of the most popular game engines, and is often sold as the indie friendly, mobile friendly engine). Standard operating procedure for Unity games is pick the latest LTS engine version as the base for your project, and don't ever update, because the updates are _so_ much work it's untenable to keep up with them. (This was official advice given to us by a unity sales rep at one point in the last 2 years).

These aren't like node updates, these are closer to Firefox removing legacy extensions, except happening quarterly. There's no guarantee that something that is "stable" in your version will work the same way in a newer version. Unfortunately, the engine is tied to specific iOS SDK versions, so in order to use a more recent iOS SDK you're forced to upgrade your unity version alongside it...

Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by howinteresting on Sunday April 24, 2022 @03:09PM (#31147203)
The idea that Unity (market cap $22 billion) should put in the work to stay compatible while Apple (market cap $2.64 trillion) should not is deplorable.
Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by maccard on Sunday April 24, 2022 @03:47PM (#31147633)
I'm certainly not making the claim you accuse me of, however Apple's compatibility is substantially better than Unity's. Apple's reasoning for breaking backwards compatibility is often sound; reducing the attack surface of misused APIs. The alternative is what you have on Android right now, a bunch of applications that still ask for the sun and moon and stars for permissions because they can. Unity's path is more of a scorched earth policy in my experience.
Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by howinteresting on Monday April 25, 2022 @02:14PM (#31158632)
I don't see why API misuse is an issue for an indie game with no online component.
Re:Apple says they're removing my game because it's more tha... by michaelt on Saturday April 23, 2022 @06:47PM (#31139411)
You do realise the tweet you're replying to is from 2017?