News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by philwelch on Saturday April 23, 2022 @07:08PM (#31139562)
And here we have a perfect example of anti-Russian bigotry.
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @07:48AM (#31143158)
Less than a hundred years ago russians marched into my country and tried to murder every man and rape every woman.

Now they're marching into Ukraine and doing the same.

You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about, you just want to "feel good" about how woke you percieve yourself to be, all the while living comfortably very far from a russian border, I'd wager. All this seems just overblown bigotry to you.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by philwelch on Sunday April 24, 2022 @04:29PM (#31148003)
And what would you suggest we do? Murder every Russian man and rape every Russian woman as collective retribution? Besides, how many Ukrainians were in the Red Army that invaded Finland in 1939? And what was the nationality of the man who ordered that invasion? By your logic, Russians, Ukrainians, and Georgians are all your enemies, so why take a side when they are fighting between themselves?

My moral stance here is to remember the distinction between a people and a regime. It’s the opposite of what the “woke” do; in fact, many of the “woke” wholeheartedly agree with you.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:18AM (#31152970)
> And what would you suggest we do?

Stop calling justified hate "bigotry". That's all. That's what I was accused of.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by philwelch on Monday April 25, 2022 @12:41PM (#31157353)
Indiscriminate hatred towards people you don’t even know, purely on the basis of what country they were born in, qualifies as bigotry. You can hold the opinion that it’s justified in this particular instance, but it is still bigotry.
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:11AM (#31143610)
> Less than a hundred years ago russians marched into my country and tried to murder every man and rape every woman.

You had better back such a sweeping statement up with hard facts and numbers as its emotional quotient veers past the red line.

The history of the human race is so rife with examples of polity A committing atrocities against people of polity B under pretexts 1, 2, … N that it does not take long of poking around to find something to embarrass nearly any ethnic group on this planet, small or large. Human beings simply do not have a lasting track record of peacefully resolving their differences and most of the time resort to the warfare instead. Sad but true.

Let's do another fact cross-check if the domain name of «.fi» in your profile rings true to the origin of your abode.

Finland joined Nazi Germany as an ally and participated in the invasion of the Soviet Union; from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuation_War#Finnish_offen...:

«On the morning of 22 June Adolf Hitler's proclamation read: "Together with their Finnish comrades in arms the heroes from Narvik stand at the edge of the Arctic Ocean. German troops under command of the conqueror of Norway, and the Finnish freedom fighters under their Marshal's command, are protecting Finnish territory».

«The Finnish plans for the offensive in Ladoga Karelia were finalised on 28 June 1941, and the first stages of the operation began on 10 July. By 16 July, VI Corps had reached the northern shore of Lake Ladoga, dividing the Soviet 7th Army, which had been tasked with defending the area. […] The Finnish II Corps started its offensive in the north of the Karelian Isthmus on 31 July. […] On 22 August, the Finnish IV Corps began its offensive south of II Corps and advanced towards Vyborg (Finnish: Viipuri). By 23 August, II Corps had reached the Vuoksi River to the east and encircled the Soviet forces defending Vyborg».

On Finland's plans concerning Eastern Karelia; from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finnish_military_administratio...:

«The Continuation War and belief in a quick German victory over the Soviet Union once again gave rise to Finnish irredentism. The legality of the Finnish claims on Eastern Karelia was justified by both ethno-cultural and military security factors. During the spring of 1941, when the Finnish political leadership understood the full extent of the German plans concerning the Soviet Union, president Ryti commissioned professor of geography Väinö Auer and historian Eino Jutikkala to demonstrate "scholarly" that Eastern Karelia formed a natural part of the Finnish living space».

On the ethnic cleansing of ethnic Russians in Easter Karelia by the Finnish government; from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Karelian_concentration_ca...:

«These camps were organized by the armed forces supreme commander Carl Gustaf Emil Mannerheim. The [Eastern Karelian concentration – emphasis is mine] camps were intended to hold camp detainees for future exchange with the Finnic population from the rest of Russia. The mortality rate of civilians in the camps was high due to famine and disease: by some estimates, 4279 civilians died in these camps, meaning a rough mortality rate of 17% […]

Significant numbers of Soviet civilians were interred in the concentration camps. These were primarily Russian women, children, and the elderly, as almost all of the working age male and female population were either drafted or evacuated by the Soviets. […] During the spring and summer of 1942, about 3,500 detainees died of malnutrition».

Granted, the situation with ethnic Russian detained in Finnish concentration camps was never as severe as in German extermination camps and the detainees did get released, several thousands did die anyway under the justification of the polity A leadership having a superiority over people of polity B. We now have gone a full circle.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:53AM (#31144004)
The soviet union illegally and unprovoked invaded Finland in 1939 and conquered territory. Then:

On 22 June 1941, Germany launched an invasion of the Soviet Union. Three days later, the Soviet Union conducted an air raid on Finnish cities, prompting Finland to declare war and allow German troops stationed in Finland to begin offensive warfare. By September 1941, Finland had regained its post–Winter War concessions to the Soviet Union: the Karelian Isthmus and Ladoga Karelia. However, the Finnish Army continued the offensive past the pre-1939 border during the conquest of East Karelia, including Petrozavodsk, and halted only around 30–32 km (19–20 mi) from the centre of Leningrad. It participated in besieging the city by cutting the northern supply routes and by digging in until 1944.

So the war you are talking about started with, again, the soviet union bombing Finland. We got hella mad and pushed them back, reclaiming our lost territories. Did we march further into russia than we needed to? Sure. Was there precedent? Absolutely. Am I a bigot for hating russians? Fuck no.

Some prisoners of war dying of malnutrition or disease is hardly an evil act from a tiny nation of farmers struggling to feed themselves while fighting to survive invasion from russia.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @12:34PM (#31145656)
> Some prisoners of war dying of malnutrition or disease is hardly an evil act from a tiny nation of farmers struggling to feed themselves while fighting to survive invasion from russia.

Lastly, you are confusing who was invading whom in 1941-44 as well as who was starving whom, intentionally or not. There is also a major logical fallacy in your reasoning of «when ABC invades my homeland, the ABC are bad; but when my people being "a tiny nation of farmers struggling to feed themselves" invade ABC in a retaliation, rightfully or not, and intern and starve women, elderly and children of ABC, that is acceptable because it is a small price to pay for what heinous things the people of ABC had previously done to my people». There has been no right party in any invasion over the course of the entire human history.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @12:46PM (#31145762)
What's the major logical fallacy?
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @11:12AM (#31144779)
> The soviet union illegally and unprovoked invaded Finland in 1939 and conquered territory.

The Soviet invasion of Finland in 1940? Yes, it was absolutely illegal, and I irrevocably concede with that fact. Finnish alliance with Nazi Germany to regain previously and forcibly ceded territories? Yes, I [can] accept that. Selective ethnic cleansing specifically targeting the ethnic Russians purely on the pretext of Karelia being the cradle of Kalevala and of the nation? Hardly so – for it is an attempt to impose and extend a sense of collective guilt upon an entire ethnic group of people for the misdeeds of their leadership they may not have agreed with.

I also note that you have evaded to provide any evidence to back up your prior statement being «Less than a hundred years ago russians marched into my country and tried to murder every man and rape every woman». Strong statements require strong evidence. The human history is full of highly unpleasant truths, but – to be able to arrive at an objective assessment of any historical situation – one has to immerse themselves in each side of the story, no matter how unpleasant it is/was. Cherry picking truths that selectively suit or support one side of the story is not an option in such a case.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @01:00PM (#31145882)
I'm not your history teacher, go read a book. If you don't know what happens to the women and children after soviets invade your country then you'll surely be shortly educated.
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by EdwardDiego on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:29AM (#31143767)
The Red Army raping its way through Germany (not sure if that is the country the comment you're replying to was referring to), is pretty well documented and agreed upon by everyone other than Russian historians.

> Finland joined Nazi Germany as an ally and participated in the invasion of the Soviet Union

When you linked to an article on the Continuation War, did you wonder why it was called the Continuation War? Not the War of Finnish Aggression?

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @11:51AM (#31145207)
> The Red Army raping its way through Germany […]

In fact, it was much worse and started way before. According to informal accounts that Russian historians silently omit due to not boding well the narrative of the glory and the purity of the Soviet victory, male Wermacht soldiers captured in trenches of the Eastern Front were frequently sexually abused and raped with material objects other than a male genitalia, such as glass bottles. The most commonly cited reason (and an excuse) is revenge for an attempt of a near total extermination of Eastern Slavs (Poles, Belarussians, Ukrainians – not just ethnic Russians). Actually, it was the Poles, the Belarussians and the Ukrainians who bore the main brunt of the Nazi brutality.

US and British troops, however, did participate in mass rapes after the fall of Berlin and West Germany as well, only to a lesser extent. Many of the Allied forces' soldiers were court martialed on the account of their involvement in mass rapes of German women. Yet, they were given a free reign in the first few days. Soviet Army was given a longer "leeway" in their rampage after which those involved in rapes and other atrocities were also court martialed. Again, the most cited reason is revenge for the murdering of 27+ million Soviet citizens. Personally, I can't accept revenge as a rationalisation of events.

> […] did you wonder why it was called the Continuation War?

Yes, I did ponder the very same question; yet, I am at a loss. Finland attacking back the Soviets on its own to regain previous losses and calling that The Continuation War? Yes, I can see a merit in that. Finland opportunistically siding with Nazi Germany, creating a pretext rooted in the nationalistic rhetoric and the Finnish epic poetry for the ethnic cleansing? No, it is a separate undertaking and not a continuation war (note the spelling).

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by moralestapia on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:46PM (#31140529)
Yeah sure, boy, particularly people who haven't lived in Russia for the past 20 years or so ...
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by native_samples on Saturday April 23, 2022 @06:53PM (#31139458)
Technically, Russian conscripts did.
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @02:03AM (#31141649)
> it's always russian people invading.

Let's cross check this statement against the historical record of invasions of what we now collectively know as Belorus, Russia and Ukraine.

A list of major invasions that took place that we have a historical record of:

- Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus' (1237–1242), a series of invasions that resulted in the Rus' states becoming vassals of the Golden Horde.

- Livonian campaign against Rus' (1240–1242), an unsuccessful Teutonic invasion of the Novgorod and Pskov Republics, in order to convert them to Catholicism.

- Russo-Crimean Wars (1570–1572), an Ottoman invasion that penetrated Russia and destroyed Moscow.

- Polish–Muscovite War (1609–1618), Poland gained Severia and Smolensk.

- Polish–Lithuanian occupation of Moscow (1610-1612). The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth occupation of Moscow took place between 1610 and 1612 during the Polish–Muscovite War, when Moscow was sacked and the Kremlin was occupied by a Polish-Lithuanian garrison under the command of Stanisław Żółkiewski.

- Ingrian War (1610–1617), a Swedish invasion which captured Novgorod and Pskov.

- Swedish invasion of Russia (1708–1709), an unsuccessful Swedish invasion, as part of the Great Northern War (1700–1721).

- French invasion of Russia (1812), an unsuccessful invasion by Napoleon's French Empire and its allies, as part of the Napoleonic Wars (1803–1815).

- Crimean War (1853–1856), a series of conflicts between the Ottoman Empire, the British Empire, France, Sardinia and the Russian Empire, including an Allied invasion of the Crimean Peninsula.

- Japanese invasion of Sakhalin (1905), an invasion and annexation by the Japanese, as part of the Russo-Japanese War (1904–1905).

- Eastern Front (World War I) (1914–1918), Russia was forced to cede Ukraine, Belarus, and the Baltic states to Germany as the Russian Empire collapsed.

- Caucasus campaign (1914–1918), a series of conflicts between the Russian Empire, its various successor states, and the Ottoman Empire during World War I.

- Allied intervention in the Russian Civil War (1918–1925) and the contemporaneous Polish–Soviet War (1918/9–1921), the Polish occupation of Belarus and West Ukraine.

- Japanese intervention in Siberia (1918–1922), an occupation of the Russian Far East by Japanese soldiers during the Russian Civil War (1917–1923).

- Operation Barbarossa (1941), an unsuccessful invasion of the Soviet Union led by Nazi Germany that started the Eastern Front (World War II) of 1941–1945.

The list above does not include constant «minor» invasions over a succession of multiple centuries of nomadic tribes (Cumans, Kipchaks, Pechenegs) from the south and from the south-east of what we now know as Russia and Kazakhstan.

If we average that list out, Russia historically has been a subject to a major invasion every 47.2 years ((1945 - 1237) ÷ 15) over the between 1237 and 1945. The 47.2 years figure is, of course, nonsensical from the historical point of view but lends a perspective of the average frequency of major invasions.

------

As a bonus, there is also a list of planned invasions:

- Kantokuen (1941), an aborted plan for a major Japanese invasion of the Russian Far East during World War II.

- Operation Unthinkable (1945), a proposed contingency plan for an Anglo-American invasion of the Soviet Union developed by the British Chiefs of Staff during the later stages of World War II.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @07:51AM (#31143177)
You misunderstand my statement. I didn't mean that "every invasion is by russian people", I meant that "when russia invades, it's the russian people doing the invasion not their leaders".
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by philwelch on Sunday April 24, 2022 @05:21PM (#31148458)
I don’t begrudge hatred towards a foreign army carrying out an invasion of conquest. I’m also fairly willing to justify relatively extreme tactics to bring such a war to a satisfactory end; for instance, I believe the atomic bombings of Japan were justified. But when you talk about indiscriminate hatred towards the Russian people, you’re including Russian people who mind their own business and have nothing to do with these invasions. You’re even including Russian people who might oppose these invasions and have done what they could to resist them.

Russia isn’t even a democracy, and it’s safe to say that it never has been. The people of Russia have always been the victims of their own autocratic regimes. If you treat them as an enemy because you are victimized by the same autocratic regime that they are, you are only furthering the interests of the regime itself, which is your true enemy and theirs.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:03AM (#31143557)
Top political leadership physically heading the country's troops in the battlefield has been unheard of since medieval ages, as this role has been delegated to the military commandership and to the army it commands long since then. Therefore I find it illogical to award the term of «statement» to the way you have chained an aggregation of words as it does not parse as a semantically or a historically valid «statement» to me.

> it's the russian people doing the invasion

Are you singling out ethnically Russian people only and are declaring that the Russian invading force in Ukraine is comprised of 100% ethnically Russian solders, or you refer to Russian citizens instead? Russia is an ethnically diverse country and is home to 193 ethnic groups nationwide, and there are soldiers in the Russian invading force who happen to be ethnically Ukrainian.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:57AM (#31144027)
I don't know what ethnics has to do with it. If it waves the flag it's of the nation. Russia is a nation of russian people. A nation with a history of illegal invasion of its peaceful neighbors, including mine.
Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by inkyoto on Sunday April 24, 2022 @12:11PM (#31145437)
> A nation with a history of illegal invasion of its peaceful neighbors, including mine.

Historical facts prove you otherwise. Historically, Russia has been far more often on the receiving end of illegal invasions (I have not even attempted to count the number of innumerable skirmishes) from "peaceful" neighbours – a major invasion every 47.2 years on average between 1237 and 1945, which is something I have pointed out before with a list of reference points to each major invasion.

Re:Ask HN: Why did the ruble stabilize and what's going on? by hypertele-Xii on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:22AM (#31153001)
You haven't proven otherwise. You've simply pointed out a different fact. Russia being frequently on the receieving end doesn't somehow annul the fact that it has a history of dishing out its own invasions.

That's like saying the Sun doesn't set, because I can prove to you it rises. It's capable of both.