News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Faster-Than-Light Neutrino Puzzle Claimed Solved by Speci... by gus_massa on Friday October 14, 2011 @06:19PM (#3113177)
When using special relativity it is extremely important to understand which inertial frame you are using. So the in the formula

  Time = Distance / Velocity
you must explicitly say in which frame you are measuring the things. It could be

  Time_EarthCenterFrame = Distance_EarthCenterFrame / Velocity_EarthCenterFrame
  Time_LaboratoryFrame = Distance_LaboratoryFrame / Velocity_LaboratoryFrame
  Time_SateliteFrame = Distance_SateliteFrame / Velocity_SateliteFrame
and it is usualy not a good idea to mix the frames like

  Time_SateliteFrame ¿=? Distance_ LaboratoryFrame / Velocity_EarthCenter  :(
In the same way, it is not a good idea to add the velocities classically with

   v_tot = c + v
you should use the relativistic correction

  v_tot = (c + v)/(1+ cv/c^2) = (c + v)/(1+ v/c) = c* (c + v)/ (c+ v) = c
so in every inertial frame the speed of light is the same.

(Really, the SateliteFrame, LaboratoryFrame and EarthCenterFrame are not inertial frames, but this is another kind of problem.)

Re:Faster-Than-Light Neutrino Puzzle Claimed Solved by Speci... by bermanoid on Friday October 14, 2011 @07:07PM (#3113327)
Actually, in this case the classical velocity addition formula is the correct one to use - the formula you mention applies to a moving reference frame, but the author's objection was that in the satellite frame the CERN folks mis-calculated the time it would take for a neutron moving to the right to meet up with a station moving to the left.

This is why to call this a relativistic objection is giving it far too much credit: the author is, quite literally, claiming that the physicists at CERN don't know how to solve a purely classical rate problem.