Re:Nearly half of Mariupol has suffered grave damage
by watwut on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:20PM
(#31126773)
Even if was was necessary, leveling residential areas of major city was not. But, that war was not necessary in the first place.
Both war and the destruction of city were optional and deliberate.
> However, we wouldn't have re-occupied cities in Iraq that resisted without leveling them and Russia wouldn't have conquered Mariupol without leveling the parts of the city that contained entrenched defenders.
Both are crimes and mass murders of civilians. Neither was necessary.
> That's the awful thing about urban warfare. Luckily we're not at genocide yet, though.
Who is that "we"? USA in Iraq did not committed genocide. Russia in Ukraine is committing one now.
Re:Nearly half of Mariupol has suffered grave damage
by caoilte on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:12PM
(#31128214)
What Russia is doing is evil. But if you call it genocide you do a cruel dis-service to the millions killed in Rwanda, the holocaust and even Ukraine during the holodomor.
Both war and the destruction of city were optional and deliberate.
> However, we wouldn't have re-occupied cities in Iraq that resisted without leveling them and Russia wouldn't have conquered Mariupol without leveling the parts of the city that contained entrenched defenders.
Both are crimes and mass murders of civilians. Neither was necessary.
> That's the awful thing about urban warfare. Luckily we're not at genocide yet, though.
Who is that "we"? USA in Iraq did not committed genocide. Russia in Ukraine is committing one now.