1) Political articles creep in
2) Political articles draw more of the politics crowd
3) Voting power of hacker crowd decreases as a percentage of total votes
4) Submit power of hacker crowd decreases as a percentage of total submits
5) This leads to a slow but steady increase in political articles
6) Go back to 1)
This is not a self-correcting system. It can and will happily veer into irrelevance because there are far more politics/reddit type users out there on the internet than there are hackers on HackerNews.
Hence why we need to apply conscious control to it, not just "submit and vote more".
It is madness to expect the same action in the same circumstances to bring anything other than the same result.
Remember that "hacker" can mean a variety of things. For YCombinator, a "hacker" is a smart person who likes to build great things, usually using the medium of software. For other communities, "hacker" might mean script kiddie, or World of Warcraft gamer, or tech fanboy. So even the current standard - on-topic = interesting to hackers - won't necessarily protect HN.
Still, the point remains, the solution isn't fleeing to somewhere else (where the problem will likely repeat). It's sticking around and submitting posts to make the community stronger (by your standards).
Technologically, I think the solution is weighting votes by karma. That would give the initial users more say AND make it harder for new users to push the community around. But that's not our decision here.
It is self evident.
Is that enough actual real world evidence? I can keep listing social sites, that this has happened to, all day long.
Testing the predicted feedback loop, especially for #1 and #2, would seem to required actual evidence of #1 and #2 happening here.
When I first joined Hacker News (near the beginning), a political article on the front page was an anomaly; in fact, I can't remember a good example of one. Sure, there were a few things in regards to the importance of Net Neutrality and how it could potentially affect the landscape of the Internet. There were a few about AT&T sharing records with the government, or Google not doing it. These are issues that have direct relevance to startups and "hackers", and there were hardly ever political debates or democrat/republican leanings expressed in the comments. Even then, I remember seeing perhaps one such submission on the front page per month.
Lately, it is strange not to see a few front page political articles per week. Not only that, but these articles are less relevant to our startups and to the lives of non-Americans. And to take the cake, their comments inevitably include at least one political debate thread, a few snarky comments, and a general lack of substance.
Many of the members who are here for hacker-related submissions simply stay away from such topics, and that is apparent from the difference in comment quality. It seems to me that there is a slow shift towards a Hacker News divide: "good" Hacker News submissions where the discussion is interesting and intellectually stimulating, and "bad" Hacker News submissions where the discussion tends more towards the things we're trying to avoid.
In a site called "Hacker News", this divide is unwelcome and senseless. That this submission has over 200 upvotes (not including one by me, by the way) is evidence of that. I would much rather see 3 submissions like this that indicate that the community is fighting back against irrelevance than to see even one submission that is dominated by political debates that could easily happen elsewhere.
People have been talking politics for centuries, and the likelihood that someone here is going to bring up a novel, interesting point is minuscule. In a community that is dominated by programmers, entrepreneurs, and other tech people, I'd much rather see discussion that might actually introduce me to brand new ideas and change my life for the better.
My hypothesis is: As this place continue to gain in popularity it will continue to become more generic and reddit like.
I hope to be proven wrong.
But almost 600 days and with a major election upcoming there have been very few mentions of it. Celebrate the positives!
You're right. I'll try to contribute more. (After a few hundred more LOC.)
Feels good just talking about it.
is this MySpace?
understand the sentiments, but this is a tad bit ridiculous. everybody talking about doing instead of doing, and getting super excited when someone suggests more talking...
Can we please have the real hn back? I miss it so much.
(Please, let's talk more about programming, less about everything else.)