News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by MaxBarraclough on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:43PM (#31112714)
Are you sure they're bundling malware just to pay for hosting? It could be the other way round: they realise GitHub might ban them for pulling that kind of thing, so they host elsewhere.

Are the mods generally FOSS? That would enable cleaned-up forks, although in the case of Filezilla this doesn't seem to have happened, which I find somewhat surprising.

Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by madaxe_again on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:21PM (#31113277)
No, they’re bundling malware because the sites that host mods are a cesspool, reminiscent of the 90’s warez scene - the downloads are all “type the third word from this page, the second word from this page, then click this sponsored link, then wait in a ‘queue’ where we show you video ads - and then you can download your mod at 20kbps”

I’m surprised they don’t split them up into 1.44mb rar archives “for your convenience”.

Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by jandrese on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:11PM (#31113944)
Those are the mod authors that get super angry when someone bundles their work into a modpack.

Luckily the modding community does a pretty good job of rewriting any egregiously bad mods like that to work around such devs.

Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by MaxBarraclough on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:03PM (#31115152)
In my experience very few, if any, mod communities take a considered approach toward licensing. Whether you're allowed to base a mod on an existing mod is left to guesswork. They're quite unlike the FOSS world in that regard. moddb doesn't even have a section for licence information, unlike, say, GitHub.

Modding communities often also take a 'permissive' approach to the copyrights of the base game, but fortunately the publishers are often wise enough not to bother taking action against such mods. A mod like [0] gets to exist despite that, ultimately, it's infringing on the base game's copyrights.

[0] https://www.moddb.com/mods/deus-ex-invisible-war-esrgan-pack

Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by ChoGGi on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:57PM (#31115086)
I'd be upset if you took my work, bundled it in a mod pack that you could be making money off of (ads etc).
Re:A cautionary tale from the decline of SourceForge by jandrese on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:18PM (#31115314)
Modpacks typically explicitly disallow making money off of it. You don't even get banner ads in the launcher.