News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by philosopher1234 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @04:04PM (#31102231)
> although I emphatically do

As someone who's gained a lot of clarity from what you've written on HN in the past, I was saddened to read this. Could you explain more about what your disagreement is?

Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by throwaway894345 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:37PM (#31103363)
> As someone who's gained a lot of clarity from what you've written on HN in the past

Flattering that you can even identify my handle (I don't even have it committed to memory).

> Could you explain more about what your disagreement is?

Sure.

1. The BLM organization (that the banner was asking people to donate to) seems shady. Leaders lead lavish lives (alliteration not intended) while it's unclear how these funds are actually benefiting the people they purport to advocate for.

2. The BLM movement is predicated on a false narrative: racist police are disproportionately killing black people. This is only true if you fail to account for obvious factors like crime rates and rates of police interaction. This is all propped up by cherry-picked and often highly-editorialized examples. America does have a problem with police killings, but it doesn't appear to be racist contra the BLM narrative, and 90+% of Americans already support police reform.

3. The BLM movement appears to have done far more damage than it has saved (and I'm not even talking about property damage). The BLM movement succeeded in pressuring police departments to minimize killings of black people, but the anti-police pressure is also very likely a primary driver in the violent crime surge which has resulted in an enormous net loss of both black lives and American lives more generally.

4. The ideologies that shroud the movement (which are variously called "critical race theory" or "wokeness" or "antiracism" or etc) reject what we might call "colorblind egalitarianism" in favor of "race consciousness" which invariably results in the reification of race. E.g., a translator is fired because he's white and the author he was to translate is black, or a white man is prohibited from volunteering on a board because there's already a white woman. Or the various strictures about who is allowed to open an Asian restaurant, host a geisha party, wear a Chinese-inspired prom dress, etc. Or the various associations of math, objectivity, literature, etc with "whiteness" or "white supremacy". I can go on and on. Of course, I this sort of "BLM racism" has also "legitimized" and animated right-wing racism, so I think we see a rise in racism on both sides of the aisle. I'm passionate about a post-racist world, and I think we're a lot worse off as a result of BLM and adjacent ideologies than we were 10 years ago.

Obviously I would support these points better if it were a longform post, but this is already very long for HN. Also, this is pretty terse (for sake of brevity), but I don't mean this to come across as combative. I'm happy to talk more about this, although given the controversial nature I'm not sure if this is the appropriate forum. :/

Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by zozbot234 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:22PM (#31103843)
It's worth noting that there are several reputable efforts pursuing criminal justice reform independently of the problematic BLM organization or movement. https://www.openphilanthropy.org/focus/us-policy/criminal-ju... has a useful overview of groups you could look into.
Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by throwaway894345 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @08:20PM (#31104719)
Thanks for the link, I’ll look into them!
Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by philosopher1234 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:04PM (#31105318)
Re (4), it seems to me like in order to change the existing influence of race on society you must first recognize it. I don’t see how everybody claiming to be colorblind when the systems and cultural institutions are structured to perpetuate racism could change anything. It seems like real color conscious changes must be made before color blindness is achievable.
Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by throwaway894345 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @11:42PM (#31105845)
I’m skeptical that there is much in the way of structural racism these days, but moreover, you can acknowledge a racist system while remaining colorblind. You can recognize that society racializes people without racializing people yourself. I don’t see how race conscious changes are helpful in the first place, much less are a prerequisite for colorblindness—if you have a racist system, it means the system isn’t colorblind, so just go straight to making it colorblind—why pass through a “color conscious” state (I also don’t understand the distinction between “color conscious” and “racist” except for connotations).

That said, I would be curious to understand what systems and cultural institutions you believe to be structurally racist and how they operate and so on.

Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by philosopher1234 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @11:51PM (#31105889)
I don’t have a developed enough view to argue this well. I’ve just been listening to a lot of Ezra Klein and engaging with a lot of leftist sources for a bit now and it’s made me much more sympathetic to these views, which previously seemed pretty empty and useless to me.

So, yea, I can’t really do it justice. It was sad for me because I’ve engaged with you in the past in defenses of Go and you made some really insightful points, so I began to count you as one of my HN heroes, and all my HN heroes (and other online heroes of mine) have left leaning politics from what I gather, so learning that you perhaps don’t required me to do some reconciling.

But yea, I can’t give a specific accounting of racist institutions.

Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by throwaway894345 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @09:19AM (#31108983)
I’m flattered, but I stay away from partisan politics as they’re often tribalistic and devoid of principle. I have a handful of left-wing positions (e.g., universal healthcare, environmentalism, etc) and I remain open minded about left-wing positions, but mostly I’m a liberal in the philosophical sense—free speech, equality, human rights, democracy, etc (I have a few right-wing positions as well, like a general preference for market-based solutions). The BLM adjacent ideologies conflict with my liberal values.
Re:Go Developer Survey 2021 Results by Beltalowda on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:08PM (#31105011)
I just hated the banned because it was large and took away even more vertical space on my already limited screen. At some point about a full quarter of the screen was these fixed banners(!!) I userCSS'd it out, but they kept changing the HTML/CSS all the time so it kept breaking.

I also don't especially like BLM as an organisation or movement because I think they're ineffective at best and contra-productive at worst, but that's okay: I don't mind seeing messages I disagree with, including on programming sites – everyone is free to use their site to promote whatever message they wish. But it's unfortunate that any conversation on this topic tend to very devolve to "against BLM = against Black people = literally Hitler!!11" or even "against banner that makes the actual page to use = against Black people = literally Hitler!!11" Well, no: I criticise BLM because I broadly agree with their goals, and am frustrated with them they are, in my opinion, not doing the right things to address them.

It's that part that I find the most annoying: it's one thing if you put up a banner and we can have a conversation about whether this is the best way to address this, whether we should address it at all, and things like that. But if that's not possible things get pretty frustrating pretty fast.