I also think they need to receive a warning before this is implemented, so that they have time to move over to another platform. I hope this was done.
If anything, you're not really arguing against the article's claim; you're simply explaining why they cannot be trusted but can't help it.
"The guy whose real fault it is" or whatever is a bit of a red herring in this context.
I feel a claim that Github cannot be trusted because they obey the law seems to be disingenuous.
Github basically gaslighting people into thinking that certain things (eg pull requests) never actually existed? It most certainly is the fault of github, they could have handled it way better.
Nice "scare quotes" at the end btw.
I put "scare quotes" as you call them to highlight the fact that the overwhelming majority of Russians support the war in Ukraine. Even in independent polling.
Honest question: do you mean Russia or do you mean the US for imposing sanctions that fail to give companies enough flexibility to do the right thing?
You can't possibly be suggesting that US law should include some random provider that would allow individuals the affordance to obey as they felt comfy about.
Do you mean “Ostracize Russian citizens individually as a proxy for ostracizing Putin?”
While there are certainly oligarchs (who have the most to loose) who have spoken out against the war, the "Z" branding is very popular in Russia with influencers and athletes brandishing it brazenly in their respective forums.
So yes, I recognize that not every Russian supports the war or Putin and that sucks for them. The reality is that the vast majority do. Pressure on Russians puts pressure on Putin and likely in a way that is more effective that hoping that the next impounded mega-yacht was actually his.
I only know of two times this has happened. The gymnast one and the rally one, which reportedly was a forced event. Every other athletic event that involves Russian athletes, like hundreds here including the hockey playoffs and figure skating, have not displayed the Z branding.
I was thinking perhaps Russians are thinking of the opposition being zombies in much the same way as right-wingers talk about NPCs.
Or maybe it's just a coincidence.
I don't know this to be true but it seems plausible to me. I'm sure there are plenty of co-opted uses/meanings of the "Z" now though.
In fact they say this:
At the same time, we are taking action to support our platform and comply with the many government mandates you’ve likely read about in the context of this war. Our legal team examines such mandates thoroughly, and we are complying with export controls and trade regulations as they evolve. This includes implementing stringent new export controls that are aimed at severely restricting Russia’s access to technologies and other items it needs to sustain its aggressive military capabilities.
That's the end of it full stop. I'm sorry this inconvenienced some open source project but this is how things like an account suspension work. This is not the death of open source or the fault of Github.
Everyone knows where the real blame lies and rather than bitch about being inconvenienced by the response, the open source author should direct their anger there. Yes, "innocent" Russians are getting swept up by the response and that sucks.