Can one split writing from the content? When I look at my own site (http://www.gwern.net), the best-written ones to me seem to be the ones with the best content. I could point to none of them (except maybe some of the fiction) where I could honestly say 'the content is jejune and juvenile, but man that's some slick writing!'

And if that's the case, then all you are really doing is asking 'hey what's popular guyz' - which is not an interesting question at all and something you can figure out yourself by looking at votes.