News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universal's Audible Watermark (2012) by CharlesW on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @01:06PM (#31085838)
> Audio watermarking is inherently audible, because that is the only way to avoid being stripped out (deliberately or inadvertently) by the incredible technology we have for removing inaudible information from audio recordings: lossy audio codecs.

You're assuming that perceptual audio coders do a perfect job at encoding what can be heard* and not encoding what can't be heard*. This isn't true in both directions — they encode detail that can't be heard* in the source, and lose detail that can be heard in the source*.

*This is contextual, depending heavily on the listener and the listening conditions.

Re:Universal's Audible Watermark (2012) by dTal on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @01:24PM (#31086084)
Not a perfect job. But a state of the art job! The relationship between watermarkers and lossy perceptual codecs is fundamentally adversarial - one side trying to eliminate all inaudible information, the other trying to sneak inaudible information past it. And so much more research has been poured into lossy compression, that the watermarkers just can't win. Bear in mind also that the watermark needs to work with all lossy codecs, so the information must be considered salient by all of them. There's just no way to do this inaudibly.
Re:Universal's Audible Watermark (2012) by karmakaze on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:33PM (#31087848)
I doubt that this is where we are at today. We have higher fidelity transmission compared to a joint-stereo 128kbps mp3, which was probably already enough to carry imperceptible watermarks.