Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by aidenn0 on Thursday October 13, 2011 @12:59PM
(#3107855)
The linked article claims that the affects on the rodents were measured even when they ran at a faster pace when not forced
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by justsomedood on Thursday October 13, 2011 @01:15PM
(#3107910)
I was curious about this as well, and the abstract from the study said:
"voluntary wheel running is characterized by rapid pace and short duration, whereas forced exercise involves a slower, more consistent pace for longer periods of time. This basic difference between the two forms of exercise is likely responsible for their differential effects on brain and behavior."
It also did say that both groups ran the same distance, but the non-forced rats did it in more sessions and a faster pace.
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by musmoerk on Thursday October 13, 2011 @02:13PM
(#3108127)
I think that in order to understand the nature of "forced" vs "voluntary" in this instance, you may have to consider how the rats normally cover distances. Humans, unlike most mammals, are designed to run for longer periods of time. Sorry if it's already been said.
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by ellyagg on Thursday October 13, 2011 @12:29PM
(#3107738)
No kidding. The emphasis on forced made it a little confusing. It seems extremely likely that the "forced" can be internal. When I'm at CrossFit, the criteria of the workout force me to exert much more strenuously than I'm comfortable with.
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by aaronblohowiak on Thursday October 13, 2011 @04:09PM
(#3108571)
From the Article:
> In one study from 2008, rats forced to run wound up with significantly more new brain cells after eight weeks than those who ran when they chose, even though the latter animals ran faster.
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by rkalla on Thursday October 13, 2011 @01:18PM
(#3107924)
ha, when I read that article all I had in my head was images of me doing death-by burpees and thinking "... I hope there are health benefits to that, because it really hurts..."
> death-by burpees
a most unpleasant way to die!
Re:Forced Exercise's Effects on the Brain
by Nessuss on Saturday October 15, 2011 @04:01AM
(#3114388)
I think the idea is that what you want to do differs from what you are doing, or what you must do. When you run faster than you're comfortable with, the will to do that comes from yourself. External forced, not using your willpower.
My guess is that the forced part of this has little to do with the effects. It's the increased intensity that is providing benefits.