News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by dmarchand90 on Monday April 18, 2022 @04:03AM (#31068409)
I swear to God I remember hearing the opposite not long ago. That frequent, smaller, meals are better as they more closely match the continual foraging of hunter-gatherers. Here's the first reference I could find: https://www.cnn.com/2017/06/02/health/mini-meals-food-drayer...

The older I get the more inconsistencies and instabilities I hear in dieting advice. I'm old enough to remember when fat was the bad guy and sugar was maybe ok

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by rmbyrro on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:04AM (#31068681)
The current diabetes epidemic is probably in large part caused by having demonized fat in the past. Food manufacturers switched to a combination of sugar and salt to restore taste after removing fat. The current health situation is what you get...
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by pigeonhole123 on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:05AM (#31068687)
Also seed oils
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by danaris on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:40AM (#31069446)
...Wait, seed oils are a problem, or seed oils have been unfairly demonized?
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by teilo on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:46AM (#31069902)
They are a problem that should be demonized.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by tintedfireglass on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:56AM (#31072421)
> They are a problem that should be demonized.

How? Aren't seed oils better than butter and palm/coconut oils due to their low saturated fat contents (canola oil or sunflower oil for example)

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by teilo on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:42AM (#31084656)
Every properly controlled independent study has shown that switching from animal fats to seed oils does nothing to reduce heart disease. It lowers cholesterol, but if lowering cholesterol does not reduce heart disease, then cholesterol is not the problem in the first place, and nor are saturated fats.

In fact, seed oils have a negative impact on health. Not only do they radically throw off the omega 6/3 balance, they are also inherently unstable in comparison to saturated fats, and they oxidize quickly. They also produce more toxic byproducts when heated.

The big farm / FDA unholy alliance that resulted in the modern western diet switching to seed oils, only made heart disease worse.

The tide has been turning for a while now, as the research has become more and more solid and obvious, but you still find plenty of farm, governmental, and medical blowhards ignoring the science, and promoting a seed-oil based diet.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by tintedfireglass on Thursday April 21, 2022 @10:34AM (#31109958)
Everything has to be balanced, you should neither claim seed oils==bad nor should you claim animal fat==unhealthy, a balanced diet should have both types of fat sources in equilibrium
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by NoThisIsMe on Monday April 18, 2022 @01:04PM (#31073463)
No. Saturated fats are not inherently bad. If anything, the good fats tend to be saturated fats.

Seed oils are typically high in omega-6 which is bad because there's way too much omega-6 in the modern diet compared to omega-3.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by tintedfireglass on Monday April 18, 2022 @10:48PM (#31079319)
I am not from a developed country so my only source of these omega3/6 is oils right? How can I remove it from my diet?
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by NoThisIsMe on Thursday April 21, 2022 @11:36PM (#31117905)
Hey, sorry, late response.

I think you should prioritize adding omega-3s over removing omega-6s.

Maybe canned anchovies or sardines? Not everyone likes them (I do!) and I don't know if they're accessible to you, but they're a great source of omega-3s and are relatively low in mercury.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by robbedpeter on Monday April 18, 2022 @04:35AM (#31068549)
If the advice comes with a story about how such and such was similar to the diets of ancestors, it's probably unscientific to the point of parody.

A wide variety in your diet prevents potential harms from chronic exposure - if you eat the same things over long periods you can accumulate unintended adulterants. Your particular genetics might result in chronic inflammation from an otherwise innocent food item.

Diet should be approached as a game with unknowable hazards. Science is continually evolving, and the findings one week can be completely overturned the next, and so on. Your strategy in the diet game should be to imitate success, avoid harmful patterns, and seek variety consistently. One day we will have a thorough model for nutrition and genetics and we can use soylent style customized food.

Meal pacing depends on your lifestyle, what you eat, fitness, and a myriad of other factors. There will be no one size fits all answer - there are too many confounding factors to reach a sensible conclusion except at an individual level.

Someone sedentary has different requirements than an athlete who runs marathons, or a warehouse worker, librarian, or plumber. One big meal might be best for one, while munching all day could be best for another, and their colleagues might find variations more suitable to their context.

One strategy is to go through an elimination experiment- eat nothing but meat, for 2 weeks, and gradually add different foods one per week, keeping a journal of subjective effects, blood pressure, satiety, weight, bowel movements, and so on.

Following a fad diet

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by robbedpeter on Monday April 18, 2022 @04:38AM (#31068564)
Can't edit. >>following a fad diet Just sets you up for disappointment. It's better to research nutrition generally and experiment methodically, building up knowledge about how you personally react to foods, and planning with that knowledge.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by inglor_cz on Monday April 18, 2022 @06:12AM (#31069020)
Maybe we should turn it around a bit.

There is a huge variation in what our ancestors ate. But modern highly processed food would be alien to all of them - no tribe nor nation on the planet ever sustained themselves on a diet of salami, pizza, French fries and massively sweetened soft drinks.

This is a very recent sea change in nutrition, where I would expect a lot of unknowable hazards to lie.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by robbedpeter on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:43AM (#31070419)
Modern foods actually makes variety simpler, since you can lump them all into one food category - modern food is often slight seasoning and proportion variations on the same processed ingredients, so you don't want to eat it frequently. An occasional pizza or birthday cake or soda is ok, but they're not great for daily food sources, especially with hfcs or lots of sugar.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by Ekaros on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:14AM (#31069314)
Even agriculture itself is in evolutionary terms recent change. Some components sure like lactose tolerance, but overall new.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by inglor_cz on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:52AM (#31069945)
There is still quite a difference between 5000 years and 25 years. Especially because in the pre-modern world, generations were much shorter than today. People would start having kids around 18.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by robbedpeter on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:47AM (#31070478)
14 or 15, often. 18 year old adults is a recent liberal human rights innovation.

There's not a whole lot of difference between humans now and humans 100,000 years ago. We have better tools and culture and knowledge, but we're physically identical - swap a baby in either direction and nobody would know the difference.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by KronisLV on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:56AM (#31068944)
> The older I get the more inconsistencies and instabilities I hear in dieting advice. I'm old enough to remember when fat was the bad guy and sugar was maybe ok

It feels to me like humanity as a whole hasn't necessarily properly figured all of this out, and might not do that in the near future.

Personally, i've found the advice of "Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants." to be rather sensible and work for me, as far as general wellbeing is concerned. If you don't eat too many processed snacks and can have a bit of exercise daily, then you should be doing pretty decently.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by inglor_cz on Monday April 18, 2022 @06:09AM (#31069011)
I like plants and I can easily reduce meat consumption to a fraction of the usual norm, but I notice that without any animal products at all, I feel sluggish. It is extra noticeable on longer hikes in uneven terrain.

Things like cheese or eggs invigorate me.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by KronisLV on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:38AM (#31069435)
That is a very fair point!

Personally it's also kind of why i wouldn't suggest that people go fully vegetarian/vegan either, except for maybe short amounts of time (e.g. should they desire to look into raising awareness, seeing what produce is sold locally etc.), since having a balanced diet can be challenging!

I occasionally get my bloodwork done and my doctor suggests that i should get a bit more vitamin D, as well as perhaps look into other multivitamin supplies during the winters, so i certainly do that (and try to eat more fish and so on).

While human diets can be slightly "experimented" with and various options be explored, i probably should add a disclaimer somewhere that the diets of pets probably shouldn't be - my dogs, for example, enjoy fresh meat pretty regularly as well as whatever the vets recommend.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by Ekaros on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:12AM (#31069303)
I believe that there is no unified correct diet. It depends on individual activity, gut fauna and genetics. And we probably know somewhat enough of one of those and looking at people in trades and like that could or should get enough activity even that might be questionable.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by KronisLV on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:33AM (#31069401)
> It depends on individual activity, gut fauna and genetics.

I'd suggest that it can also depend on where one lives: the "optimal" diets of someone in Egypt, Norway and Australia might all differ as well, due to the different conditions in each place.

That said, it's not like we can't offer some general recommendations for most folk: someone who subsists off of processed foods with plenty of sugar/palm oil in them is unlikely to be that much healthier than someone who has a reasonable amount of vegetables/greens in their meals.

Though the more specific you try to get, the more curious things become: for example, the statement about eating more plant based stuff might have some opponents in the circles of people who are going for a keto diet - while i can't comment on how effective/healthy it is, i find it interesting and worthy of consideration as well.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by Ekaros on Monday April 18, 2022 @08:17AM (#31069688)
It actually always surprises me just how long human can live when they don't outright starve to death. Or reach crazy levels of obesity (like multiple hundreds of kilograms.

And as person without kids I wonder what is good enough lifespan anyway if you are happy during it 40, 50 or 60 years? Or has it go to close to 80 or 90?

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by jseban on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:22AM (#31068776)
The biggest positive effect of frequent smaller meals is steady blood sugar, which will have a very obvious impact on your mood and concentration. It also gives the body a more steady supply of nutrients, which is going to be better for any slow running activity of recovery.

The downside I guess is that you always have some proportion of your body's energy working on digestion, which could lower peak performance. And obviously that it takes more time.

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by SnowHill9902 on Monday April 18, 2022 @06:57AM (#31069243)
You are underestimating the capacity of the human body. A healthy human body can perfectly well maintain blood sugar levels with or without eating food regularly.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by legulere on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:46AM (#31081222)
Nutrition science is difficult. Most of the times it's impossible to do randomized studies on humans. Most of the times it's impossible to do blind studies. The effect sizes are relatively small and show up only after a long period. The human body is very adaptive to very different kind of diets.
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by the_gipsy on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:44AM (#31068878)
It's all pseudoscience, very contradictory
Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by smokey_circles on Monday April 18, 2022 @05:31AM (#31068814)
It is the nature of science that we change our mind as we learn new things.

But sugar was never OK. That was pseudo-science.

A lot of dietary "information" is pseudo-science. It's not an area we've dedicated a lot of effort into because we came up with a food pyramid one time and that was that.

We're still learning how wrong we are, as is the case in most fields

Re:Should we be eating three meals a day? by hansthehorse on Monday April 18, 2022 @07:04PM (#31077814)
It's amazing how much sugar is in almost everything. I made an effort to cut out as much added sugar as I could and it's exhausting. There are over 50 synonyms for sugar that food companies use.