Well, you do. I'm over the hill and I'm objectively more capable than I was in my 20s. It's possible for this to be true despite declining cognition.
My abilities differ. In my 20s I relied on sheer problem solving ability. I could focus for days on a problem. I think I could better visualize specifics and more reliably remember.
Wisdom is different. Later in life I find I'm more able to navigate deeper social issues, more capable of seeing bigger picture patterns. I manage myself better, and these higher order changes result in my getting a lot more done than when I was younger.
There's much more to real world brain performance than certain narrow measures of technical capability.
I assume people doing subtle physical and mental activities (danse, music, craft) can maintain both.
And in fact, this «putting to rest» thing is nonsense, unless somebody really believed that the brain gets younger with age. The real point is about how heavily or how little degeneration impacts proficiency.