Phrenology has had its adherents over the years, none that I know of were successful in proving any real predictive power though.
Brain size and intelligence seem to only be correlated in the loosest of ways anyway. Everything we know about performance of information processing systems says that their size and weight is almost irrelevant compared with their design. We expect simple algorithmic optimizations to provide orders of magnitude of improvement, and more advanced ones to provide more orders of magnitude on top of that.
If I recall rightly the metric with the best performance is ratio of brain to body mass. This would make sense if you assume that brain performance is determined largely by its 'design' and scales only modestly with mass, and that creatures of the same species share the same design.
It's been proven that brain size has close to nothing to do with intelligence. Hell, some people get half of their brains removed to stop intractable seizures and if it happens as a child they tend to recover completely and live normal lives
Does anyone know of a company (or university, govt. agency, etc.) which hired or promoted on the basis of "physically larger brains perform better" - and was actually successful with that? Probably using some rough cranial measurements as a proxy for brain size, vs. MRI's.
I'd bet that the real-world performance of that strategy would be considerably worse than random chance, due to various knock-on effects.