Re:Twitter Should Open Up the Algorithm
by CharlesW on Saturday April 16, 2022 @11:29AM
(#31053079)
"Open up the algorithm" is such a charmingly naive take on community moderation at scale that I can almost forgive the author for literally parroting Musk as the source of a lightweight take synthesized mostly from other people's thoughts in order to attract attention to his "Every" newsletter platform.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think that's a way to call for transparency. For instance, if they say they don't shadow ban people, then it should be evident in the code. And it would force them to have a clear process for things like search without any "nudging" or social manipulation.
Re:Twitter Should Open Up the Algorithm
by paulsutter on Saturday April 16, 2022 @12:12PM
(#31053482)
Do you consider Jack Dorsey naive on the subject?
"The choice of which algorithm to use (or not) should be open to everyone" - Jack Dorsey
Re:Twitter Should Open Up the Algorithm
by powerslacker on Saturday April 16, 2022 @12:55PM
(#31053914)
I sure do. "The algorithm" fits nicely in articles complaining about unfair treatment, but it's not a real thing. Any mildly complicated reccomendation system is going to be 1) more than a single algorithm 2) far beyond the reasoning skills of laymen.
> Do you consider Jack Dorsey naive on the subject?
On the contrary, Jack knows what he's talking about and wants this because it would allow him to abdicate responsibility for Twitter platform moderation.
given that Jack Dorsey is also on the record for claiming that Bitcoin will lead to world peace I think it's fair to say the answer to that question is yes.
What makes in your opinion the request naive? Too complex to open source or for people to analyze and criticize? I see some people becoming Twitter algorithm experts as we also have Linux kernel developers
"Open up the algorithm" is a fantasy where you point a function at a tweet and it returns a boolean. In reality, content moderation at this scale is a complex problem that requires a sophisticated system of many parallel strategies (some of which are more automatable, some less) and many thousands of people to manage.
Is in your opinion the Twitter moderation algorithm more complicated than the Linux Kernel or Bitcoin software code bases? Those are audited and modified publicly al the time. The human part can also be audited if the rules are stated clearly and an explanation is always given when an action is taken.
How do you know? Where did you come up with evidence to confirm that statement? There has never been a platform as large as Twitter that opened up its algorithm.
As an example, the bits of Google's original algorithms that they did talk about (pagerank using reputation of in-links to propagate to a page) publicly began getting gamed into irrelevance fairly early on (link-for-link schemes being the start of the SEO industry). After that it's been a continuing struggle of a whole industry looking for weaknesses and Google adapting.
Another way of thinking about it, is that if someone could see what features were most important for the ranking on some site, then they could start to optimize for those, breaking the usefulness of that feature. One obvious example of this is "Please remember to like, comment, and subscribe" on YouTube.
For a long period of time, Reddit used to be open source. It can be done, plus additional changes to add transparency on top, like giving people the option to switch between different recommendation algorithms, making it clear why content was recommended, and so forth.