News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon workers at 100 more facilities want to unionize: A... by throwaway09223 on Thursday April 14, 2022 @12:44PM (#31029464)
Your summary is simply not what took place above. I suggest you re-read the comment thread. Here are some specific links to help you improve your notes:

"Ah, well I wrongly assumed you worked ... Congrats, you’re now living off the efforts of others," https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31010666

"You feel your interests are different from someone making 30k/year, ... you have much more in common with a warehouse worker ..." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31010143

The entire comment thread centers around ad-hominem appeals rather than substantive analysis.

Re:Amazon workers at 100 more facilities want to unionize: A... by ABCLAW on Thursday April 14, 2022 @03:36PM (#31032210)
>Your summary is simply not what took place above.

You seem dead set on doing anything other than actually engaging with the substance of the post. I didn't say the term 'you' wasn't used. I said the argument has nothing to do with you, or perhaps more accurately, it doesn't rely on any lived experience you've had - you're irrelevant to the point being made.

Let's look at a sample argument: My eyes generally see things well, I see that the sky is blue, therefore, since I trust my eyes, the sky is blue.

In this argument, we have 1) A premise, 2) Evidence, 3) Rationale, and 4) A conclusion.

Let's modify the argument a bit. My eyes generally see things well, I see that the sky is blue - and so does everyone including you, therefore, since I trust my eyes, the sky is blue.

The element we've added here, that everyone sees that the sky is blue, is not evidence in support of my conclusion, because my rationale depends on my trust in my eyes, not my trust in everyone else's. Disagreeing by stating "Blind people don't see that the sky is blue, so your evidence is faulty and your conclusion doesn't stand - the sky isn't blue because of blind people" is a poor critique; there ARE weaknesses in the argument, to be sure, but that isn't one of them.

To return to this thread, you're attacking elements of the post which aren't the core of the argument; they're attempts to make the argument cogent to you (which obviously failed), but aren't elements upon which the argument relies upon.

Anyways, you're clearly not arguing in good faith - there's no attempt to interface with ANY of the content being posted. I'm done here.

Re:Amazon workers at 100 more facilities want to unionize: A... by throwaway09223 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @03:03PM (#31055109)
> you're attacking elements of the post which aren't the core of the argument

This is also trivially disproved, for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31008817

> they're attempts to make the argument cogent to you (which obviously failed)

I'm really uninterested in the justifications for introducing ad-hominem argumentation -- which, to be clear, rapidly devolved into attacks.