News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by hedora on Thursday April 14, 2022 @11:47AM (#31028513)
In true HN fashion, first-mover / market-leader Sonos isn't even mentioned yet.

The reason there isn't a standard (other than Sonos, or those discontinued Chromecast dongles) is that you need the following to work seamlessly:

- network attached DAC of some sort (in-speaker, or not; don't care)

- iOS app

- Android app

- the top 10 streaming services

- radio streaming directories, like TuneIn, or the open source ones.

- airplay

- Chromecast

- network / device auto discovery

- sound synchronization

- power management

- desktop apps

- NFS/cifs/etc bridge

- hdmi/fiber/??? bridge

- N.M surround sound (for N = 2, 3,5,7,9 and M=0,1,2)

- Some battery powered, waterproof speaker that works in direct sunlight on hot days

- Hardware distribution at places like IKEA, BestBuy, Amazon, etc.

- A healthy used hardware market

- 10+ year support lifetimes on the speakers + amps (note: discrete, cheap DAC dongles could disrupt sonos on this point)

And other things I forgot about.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by darrenf on Thursday April 14, 2022 @11:59AM (#31028702)
> In true HN fashion, first-mover / market-leader Sonos isn't even mentioned yet.

I bought my first Sonos device last year, the Roam. Using it as a bluetooth speaker is fine and I love the sound and portability, but oh boy do I hate the experience of trying to use Sonos services over wifi.

Nine times out of ten, perhaps even more often, the iOS app says it can't connect and "let's fix it". If I go through the slow reconnection wizard it invariably ends up telling me to reboot my router(!?). I learned to either switch the Roam on/off a bunch of times, or kill and restart the app a bunch of times, before the app eventually decides yes, it can find the device ... only to then fail again when half hour later I want to add something else to the queue or switch station.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by phlipski on Thursday April 14, 2022 @12:07PM (#31028834)
Interesting. My experience with the Sonos app has been a revelation in GOOD audio networking experiences. It just works. I download the app - connect to a play 1/3/5 near me and stream music. All in the space of about 2 minutes. Nothing else I've tried comes close to this experience.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by hedora on Thursday April 14, 2022 @01:17PM (#31030023)
I've had a (S1) sonos for many years. That only happens to me if the speakers (or phone) are repeatedly falling off the WiFi network.

Try plugging into Ethernet, or placing it close to your router. If that fixes it, then you have a root cause.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by darrenf on Friday April 15, 2022 @05:59AM (#31038353)
The roam has no Ethernet port. It holding a wifi signal has never been a problem (if I set it playing something, I can’t recall it ever having stopped)

Someone else has contacted me privately and recommended I switch off private MAC address on my phone. That seems to have improved things.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday April 14, 2022 @05:20PM (#31033456)
> In true HN fashion, first-mover / market-leader Sonos isn't even mentioned yet.

market leader? no idea. first-mover? wrong. Slim Devices were the first mover in this space with the Squeezebox (subsequently purchased by Logitech). Sonos came shortly afterwards.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol? by yehBu77 on Thursday April 14, 2022 @12:28PM (#31029185)
In true HN fashion they ignore people were pirating and streaming content to multiple rooms before a big company brand caught onto the idea and profited from it.

I have multi-room streaming using “dumb” speakers, and copper wire (for audio and network). I control one content box and aim it at different speakers from my phone, tablet, laptop. Siri Shortcuts decouple me from waiting for an MBA to approve adding voice commands.

I know; brave flex sticking with simple wire versus going wireless.