Re:The gambler's fallacy is not a fallacy?
by pdonis on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @09:46PM
(#31022532)
> This is straight up false because you know a priori that the chance is 50-50.
Not necessarily. As the article notes, the way humans normally toss coins, the coin has about a 51% chance to land on the side that was facing up at the start of the toss.
The more general point here is that the odds for a coin toss are not a property of the coin by itself; they are a property of the coin and the process that is used to toss it. IIRC E. T. Jaynes in his book on probability theory described experiments with a robotic coin flipper where it was found that the odds could be skewed quite significantly by properly designing and calibrating the flipper.
> If you don’t know they’re independent and you’re trying to identify the pattern that’s just an experiment.
Yes, I think most of the article would be better described as how to experimentally test for the actual odds of a process like repeated coin flips, given several possible hypotheses about how the process works.
> Yeah they do. At the roulette table, all the time. Gamblers do this a lot, which is where it gets its name.
Yes, the biggest missing piece I see in the article is any actual discussion of how actual gamblers in the real world behave.
Not necessarily. As the article notes, the way humans normally toss coins, the coin has about a 51% chance to land on the side that was facing up at the start of the toss.
The more general point here is that the odds for a coin toss are not a property of the coin by itself; they are a property of the coin and the process that is used to toss it. IIRC E. T. Jaynes in his book on probability theory described experiments with a robotic coin flipper where it was found that the odds could be skewed quite significantly by properly designing and calibrating the flipper.
> If you don’t know they’re independent and you’re trying to identify the pattern that’s just an experiment.
Yes, I think most of the article would be better described as how to experimentally test for the actual odds of a process like repeated coin flips, given several possible hypotheses about how the process works.
> Yeah they do. At the roulette table, all the time. Gamblers do this a lot, which is where it gets its name.
Yes, the biggest missing piece I see in the article is any actual discussion of how actual gamblers in the real world behave.