Re:The gambler's fallacy is not a fallacy?
by noduerme on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @09:10PM
(#31022313)
On its face, the simple fact that you have a 75% chance of not flipping a coin heads twice in a row is cognitively at odds with the fact that you have a 50% chance of doing it on the second flip... if you know you flipped heads the first time. If you didn't have the knowledge of what the first flip was, your known odds on the second flip completing two heads would still be 25%. Which seems to intuitively imply that prior knowledge is valuable.
Also, say you're about to flip a coin 100 times. Then, your future-self advises you that you're 50% likely to get Heads on any particular flip. Then, sure, that'd seem to imply that you're going to get 50 Head's and 50 Tail's, so switching would often make sense as getting one result would tend to reduce that result's likelihood. In particular, you should be able to guess the last flip with certainty, as you know that you ought to get a total of 50 Head's and 50 Tail's.
However, if you're flipping a coin 100 times and estimate a 50% likelihood of Head's, then that's a different scenario. I mean, yes -- you're still working under the assumption that Heads is 50% likely, but it's not the same thing. You wouldn't know that the final distribution would be 50 Head's and 50 Tail's, such that getting one result wouldn't have the same implications.
Finally, "the gambler's fallacy" is named after a stereotypical scenario wherein a gambler who keeps losing argues that they'd be a fool to quit because they're "overdue" for a win. In that case, it does tend to be a fallacy. So if you come up with a situation where such an argument wouldn't be a fallacy, then presumably you're looking at something other than the gambler's-fallacy.