But of course it is. If I spend a year writing a book, ownership of the book is now capital. I may sell copies of the book (in digital form to keep things clear) for decades to come. The capital resource in this case generates income without additional labor on my part after its construction, and no labor on anyone else's part, ever.
> I do not believe you understood.
I do understand.
Your perspective stems from a measure of free agency. Mine stems from a measure of relative value.
Your perspective is useful when reasoning about moral issues related to overwork. For example, we should provide for those who cannot provide for themselves - so they do not cease to exist as you put it.
It is not so useful when reasoning about how to value the actual work output.
You spend a year writing a book.
Labor rendered ideas into a form others can use.
It is capital. It is also a means. And it is a book.
Now you sell copies, right?
Capital did not sell copies. You did, and you had to labor to do that.
In the digital case, literally thousands of people and their labor copy, distribute and take payment for your book. It takes a lot of people to maintain that network your book is on.
Capital can amplify labor. That is a tool, device, mechanism.
Capital can compensate others for labor too.
What it does not do is create. That is what people do. That is what labor is.
In reality, I do not labor when someone orders something from my online store. The process is automated. The income is passive.
In fact, according to your line of argument, capital investments are labor too. Even if we accept the argument (which I don't) it utterly counters your position.
Just nonsense.
Technology is an amazing thing, isn't it?
Your hard year of labor to make your book will see more readers, at a lower cost per acquiring readers than was possible before!
I do not follow your capital investment argument. Go ahead, put it out there. What are you thinking?
Let's talk it through.
This is a fairly high value conversation. It always is every time I have it.
Ideally, we build to a point where very little labor is required. We will have created great wealth!
Which brings me back to how we value people, labor, etc...
Some of us will still be doing the basics. Should those people not see some greater measure of that in their lives? Clearly, we will be able afford it.
In any case, using some Latin does not change the hard facts though. I am stating a fact to you. It is not opinion.
No, it is not ever created with capital.
Capital does not have agency. It is a vehicle for the product of labor. By itself, it is nothing.
This can be confusing and hard to see. Take it back to basic principles and it becomes much easier.
>Everyone has the same amount of time in a day. A better way to phrase this is that some people produce more wealth per unit of time than others.
I do not believe you understood.
Our lives are roughly divided into thirds. One to sleep, one to work, one to live.
When costs and risks are high, more time is required to meet them, and when unmet, people cease to exist.
Poor people's lives are basically two thirds work, one to sleep. Essentially, very little time not purposed for them. They work all the time and have no choice in the matter.
This can also be expressed as having little to no free agency.
Very wealthy people have almost none of their time purposed for them. This can be expressed as having almost entirely free agency. They may work all the time, or be at leisure. Their choice.