Re:Why your new programming language won't work
by dasil003 on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @11:06PM
(#3101325)
> I'm not sure I understand where the pandering was, and for me the post certainly wasn't pointless
Yes it's not pointless the first time you see it. Where it becomes pointless is on Slashdot any time there is ever an article about a new program language and 2 or 3 people fill it out for the comments.
Re:Why your new programming language won't work
by nknight on Wednesday October 12, 2011 @01:11AM
(#3101587)
Thankfully, HN's content is not governed by the content of Slashdot's comments.
Re:Why your new programming language won't work
by dasil003 on Thursday October 13, 2011 @01:44PM
(#3108006)
Amen to that. I don't know why I have to be downvoted just for pointing out that these things are not necessarily annoying per se, just when they become relentless memes by which a community validates itself.
I read it as a humorous warning to would-be language designers of the challenges and pitfalls of coming up with a new syntax, compiler, runtime, etc. A quick run-through of the items in the checklist should give you a hint these guys seem to know what they're talking about. Click the bio links above the article and those suspicions will be confirmed.
Sure there's a bit of snark here, but it serves a purpose, as does the humor. They obviously put some thought and time into this, they have some strong and worthwhile opinions about language design and the expertise to back it up.
Now, if it were Zed Shaw or Joe Damato up there, I'd totally agree with you. Kidding!!