It's actually not so easy to assume that hallucinogen-naive test subjects will know the difference between psilocybin and placebo. Knowing the effects of a hallucinogen (i.e. reading about them) and actually experiencing the effects are quite different.
At least, this is something I found surprising after experiencing a hallucinogen (or any psychoactive drug besides caffeine) for the first time.
Going from caffeine and occasional marijuana to mushrooms was wild. You'd have a better chance of learning how to fly a helicopter from a book than understanding what psychedelics will feel like by reading or listening. Naive users might get fooled by a niacin flush or placebo, but once you've experienced it (and paid attention) there's no way you'll mistake the real thing.
It also gives you the perspective needed to appreciate music like Shpongle and hippie intellectuals like McKenna and Watts. If you haven't experienced psychedelics, you're like a blind person being told about colors. You literally can't understand it until you live through it. Like orgasms or childbirth or religious ecstasy, some things transcend mere explanation.
Psychedelics are great since they give you a shortcut right into the matrix, and you're confronted with the fact that you are indeed in a simulation, and that your existence in relation to the rest of the universe isn't nearly as distinct and cleanly delineated as you thought.
The radical changes in personality stem from whatever neural machinery that governs openness to experience. I think it makes sense that the change makes people less depressed and anxious. You allow yourself to pay attention to other things, and it becomes easier to avoid fixating and catastrophizing everything wrong in your life.
I'd like to see a trial in which the participants are unconscious for the duration of the "trip". This would not only be trivially blinded, but also help to establish whether the antidepressant effect stems entirely from the subjective experience, or whether there's a chemical component as well.
People always say, "the trip is integral!". But we don't actually know that, do we?