Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by rgrieselhuber on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:23AM
(#30989148)
I think it pays to be more specific. Carbon is a generic term that can include all carbon-based lifeforms, including humans. Also, taxing normal people for CO2 emissions just gives more money to the people who designed these systems in the first place.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by allemagne on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:33PM
(#30991213)
If you tax CO2 emissions by everyone, and then distribute the money equally among the population, normal people end up with more money afterwards because they tend to emit less CO2 than rich people.
It is also better at reducing emissions, because then less CO2-intensive options become cheaper than the alternative.
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by rgrieselhuber on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:35PM
(#30991237)
And who will be in charge of making sure that happens?
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by allemagne on Monday April 11, 2022 @06:03PM
(#30995683)
Sounds like you have a great method of shooting down ideas based on something besides their own merits.
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by rgrieselhuber on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:53PM
(#30997669)
It’s just a simple question. If we’re going to add more to the tax burden with the promise that the money then be equally distributed, it’s fair to wonder who would be in charge of making sure it’s actually done correctly.
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by imtringued on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @05:15AM
(#31000307)
Your complaint is valid. Politicians should implement the dividend first and then start taxing to align incentives.
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @07:50AM
(#31001319)
Now we’re talking. The best way to sell it will be to call it a tax reduction and start by reducing the tax burden on people with a net worth less than $1B, adjusted for inflation. Then fund the entire program to align incentives by implementing a CO2 tax on those with a net worth of > $1B, inflation adjusted, with no loopholes for deductions. Do that and outlaw lobbying and it would have a chance at working.
Re:I liked the idea of carbon offsets until I tried to expla...
by intrasight on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:01AM
(#30989752)
I should get a tax credit - for being mostly sequestered carbon ;)