So the tradeoff doesn't seem reasonable to me at this point in time. Next summer there will be different chips, a redesigned form factor (probably) and better LTE coverage and so the tradeoff will go the other way.
I wasn't suggesting that it was impossible if you were designing from scratch.
Battery life is important. So yes you can sacrifice battery life for more power hungry 1st generation chips but it isn't wrong to decide that the battery life is more important.
Seems like the effective CPU+GPU capability of the iPhone 4S is at the head of the pack. When you add in the overhead that Android software has I don't think it is necessary for Apple to goose the processor specs in order to get fantastic end-user experience. This also saves power. Again tradeoffs that have to be made and the ones Apple picked seem entirely reasonable to lots of customers (based on pre-sales orders).
I guess from where I'm sitting, I'm used to Apple kicking everyone in the nards from a tech specs perspective, and I don't think that's the case this go-around.