News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heresy by Osmose on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:41AM (#30978068)
The behavior he's calling "heresy" here cannot be evaluated in a vacuum; these kinds of statements are all contextual, ESPECIALLY hinging on who is saying them. And the reason that is the case is because the consequences of saying something are different depending on who says them.

Paul Graham is wealthy and influential, and actively tries to influence folks with essays like this. So when he says something, it is judged in a harsher light because those words have a much stronger effect than if, say, some L2 software engineer on Twitter said them. If PG says something that _could_ be interpreted as racist, it threatens to normalize believing that in the minds of the people who follow him. If L2 says something that is on the fence, at worst some of their immediate friends will pile on to them about how uncool that was (barring the rare occasions of people going viral for bad takes, which is an outlier).

I think that's reasonable social policing to keep our discourse healthy. Having that influence over people demands a price in return. If PG wanted to stop getting pushback for approaching what society thinks is an acceptable line, he totally can, he just needs to rebrand and get out of the startup game.

Re:Heresy by teakettle42 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:26PM (#30978632)
You have invented a “harm principle” to be used when evaluating truth, and the fact that you think this is a cogent argument is scarier than anything Paul Graham might have said.

One’s right to say something isn’t curtailed just because their saying it might intrude on your dogma more strongly than if it was said by someone with less social power.

Re:Heresy by Osmose on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:41PM (#30978808)
If I'm following you correctly, you're implying that in order to debate with others to determine what truth is, you must have the freedom to say things without being bound by how the act of saying them would affect other people, right?

And I'm disagreeing and saying that, unless you have some sort of prior agreement with the people involved (which social media/the internet/readers of your blog don't have), you don't get to avoid consequences for the potential harm saying something might cause. Ultimately you are always talking to be heard by someone else, and all human interaction involves the risk of harming/angering someone else, but every day we control for that risk in how we say things and who we say them to.

Re:Heresy by wrren on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:57PM (#30978995)
Your conflating harming people with causing them anger is very much part of the problem. 'Harm' used to mean something much more severe; now it basically means anything at or above pissing someone off.

The same concept creep has occurred when it comes to the word 'violence' too. As a society, we long ago drew red lines at behaviours that are violent or harm people, but thanks to these deliberate redefinitions, extreme responses are somehow justified to utterly non-consequential speech, because people accept that speech can cause 'harm' or is 'violent'.

It's such a cheap rhetorical trick that does nothing but chill public discourse while doing nothing to positively impact the lives of the people it's ostensibly supposed to protect.

Re:Heresy by nitrogen on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:13PM (#30979194)
Even the absence of speech has also been described in those same terms. This category of rhetorical double bind is counterproductive to progress.
Re:Heresy by the8472 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:02PM (#30979050)
Truth is harmful and people need to be shielded from it? If we hold the speakers responsible, rather the people who take up their words and turn them into actions? Then isn't that incompatible with democracy which relies on informed citizens that aren't easily captured?
Re:Heresy by bloaf on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:12PM (#30979909)
> And I'm disagreeing and saying that, unless you have some sort of prior agreement with the people involved (which social media/the internet/readers of your blog don't have), you don't get to avoid consequences for the potential harm saying something might cause. Ultimately you are always talking to be heard by someone else, and all human interaction involves the risk of harming/angering someone else, but every day we control for that risk in how we say

I think this is the crux of the issue. The internet (including social media/the internet/blogosphere) originated in academia and was first populated by academics. People like PG (and myself) who grew up in that environment still feel like the internet is-and-ought-to-be a free marketplace of ideas, where academically-minded people can dispassionately debate on any topic. In our view, the Internet's virtues are the age-old virtues of the liberal arts, and that it would be a liberalizing and liberating force as it spread to the public.

But the internet has grown organically. It has been September for almost three decades now.

The internet is more representative of the population at large, and we are being reminded why academia is described as an ivory tower and concepts like tenure exist. Fundamentally, not everyone can be an academic, nor can they tolerate the existence of academics. The "towers" and "tenure" exist as a two way shield: it both mitigates self-censorship among academics by protecting them from mob backlash, and it prevents the "think with our gut" mob from getting indigestion and hurting themselves.

So I think both that you're right, and that it is a shame. The internet has not changed the public's unworthiness to engage in academic conversation despite the oceans of information it has made available. The public will misunderstand and misconstrue and mistrust and misuse academic ideas in ways that harm people, and that harm will be the fault of the academics for not knowing better than to keep their ideas to themselves. Just like it is the witches fault for admitting that they thought differently than their community.

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:21PM (#30980015)
Academia has never been dispassionate. The very idea of an academic conference started because academics hated each other so much that they needed a mechanism for them to see each other as people.

Further, a marketplace of ideas is a marketplace. Marketplaces are not emotionless voids where consumers dispassionately select the product that will provide them with precisely the best utility-to-cost ratio. They are emotional places where concepts like marketing and signaling are extremely important. Similarly, we'd expect a "marketplace of ideas" to be an emotional place and for human emotion to be a consideration when adopting ideas.

Re:Heresy by bloaf on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:36PM (#30980216)
I agree, certainly not all academics live up to that virtue; but it is still a virtue of academia.
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:24PM (#30980734)
I do not believe that it has ever been a virtue of academia.
Re:Heresy by twofornone on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:02PM (#30979052)
This is carte blanche to silence any opinion you (or your mob) doesn't like and its absurd that people think its valid. Completely flies in the face of the spirit of freedom of expression.

There are arguments that need to be expressed even though ideologues may think that they are harmful. That's the point of open discussion. There are questions that need to be asked even if others believe they may have inconvenient answers. That's the point of objective science. Because of sentiment like yours, we increasingly have neither, and we are all worse off for it.

Re:Heresy by photochemsyn on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:01PM (#30979044)
I'd just note here that 'truth through debate' is an ancient concept (Socrates - Aristotle - Plato etc.) that has been replaced with 'truth through experiment and observation' (Galileo - Newton - Maxwell - Einstein etc.). Of course many have attempted to use science to justify their behavior or to justify some arbitray human social organizations (i.e. Francis Galton and Social Darwinism, or Lysenko in the USSR and Phenotypic Modification, or more simply, nature vs. nurture).

However, science isn't the final arbiter for marking out the optimal societal norms, whatever those may be, although this seems to be the meaning of 'truth' as you use it in this context. An authoriarian state with zero personal freedom might be just as capable of feeding its human population as a libertarian state with a minimal set of legal restrictions, for example.

Re:Heresy by bloaf on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:26PM (#30979362)
The courts, to this day, still believe in 'truth through debate.'

Science does too, although the debaters are generally expected to be working towards developing empirical ways of settling their disagreements. I believe it was Gell-Mann who famously tells a story of holding on to his theory because of its beauty despite several experiments indicating it was wrong, and eventually being vindicated.

Re:Heresy by pfortuny on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:02PM (#30979053)
Pain is not harm.

Suffering is not necessarily bad.

One can live a full life in the midst of hurting.

The fact that Santa does not exist angers a lot of people each year…

Re:Heresy by dragonwriter on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:06PM (#30979104)
> Pain is not harm

Yes, pain = experienced disutility = harm.

> Suffering is not necessarily bad.

Suffering is itself bad, but may be an acceptable cost for some greater good, sure.

> One can live a full life in the midst of hurting.

Sure, it's possible to do one despite the other, but that doesn't negate that the latter is bad compared to it's absence, all other things being equal.

Re:Heresy by prepend on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:58PM (#30981087)
> Yes, pain = experienced disutility = harm.

Exercising is painful, yet it is not harm. There is “good pain” (ie, muscles being stretched out and hurting after a good workout) and “bad pain” (ie, popping a joint out of socket causing an injury).

Not all pain is harmful.

Emotionally, grief is painful, but it’s sometimes necessary and helpful to grieve over a loss.

Re:Heresy by convolvatron on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:51PM (#30978925)
wow. I guess we should just stop speaking altogether
Re:Heresy by solatic on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:52PM (#30978940)
You're equivocating between rational and emotional truths.

Rationally, only one thing can be true. This is what's most useful when applying the scientific method. Scientifically, there isn't such a thing as heresy - only rejecting the null hypothesis, or failing to reject it.

But people are not rational beings. The same message, delivered in the same way, can upset some people and not others. People do not react rationally. Trying to deny this (and claim that people are rational beings), in and of itself, denies a scientific truth.

Re:Heresy by convolvatron on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:05PM (#30979088)
no one should dispute that people might react emotionally to statements.

that doesn't necessarily imply that all speakers should accept the burden to be so inoffensive that _no_ listener would react negatively.

Re:Heresy by solatic on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:20PM (#30979293)
> that doesn't necessarily imply that all speakers should accept the burden to be so inoffensive that _no_ listener would react negatively.

No, it doesn't imply that. But let's unpack the presumption behind your statement.

We all know that there are people in the world with whom we have deep and fundamental disagreement. Religious people are aware that there are atheists; classical liberals are aware that there are autocrats and theocrats, etc. Does that, in and of itself, upset us so deeply that we take offense at it? I daresay no.

What causes one to take offense is the uttering of "heresy" by someone nearby, where such utterance affects them personally. Which means that it is incumbent upon us to know who is listening to us. There is a wide emotional gulf between a preacher who preaches to his congregation and a preacher who proselytizes and seeks converts. Same message, different audience. In the first case, the preacher is among fellows. In the second, the preacher is among those who may not be so open to what he has to say. The preacher who decides to proselytize fundamentally accepts an additional burden, if the preacher has any hope at succeeding. And a preacher who does not accept that burden, does not even recognize that such a burden exists, who tries to communicate the same message in the same way regardless of who is in the audience, well, that preacher should only see his failure as foreseeable and expected.

"Preacher", above, if it wasn't clear, is not a religious term. It refers to anybody who has any kind of message that actually tries to persuade others, rather than merely seeking the empathy of like-minded friends and family.

Re:Heresy by convolvatron on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:30PM (#30979413)
ok. yes. we should certainly be cognisant that unless we are careful, our message might be not be received in the spirit that it was intended. and I am certainly running the risk of being dismissed out of hand by saying something that is unnecessarily offensive.

but these are pragmatic matters for people who are actually trying to proselytize. I fundamentally disagree that the speaker is somehow morally responsible to not violate the listeners preconceptions - that undermines the greatest tool we have as a society.

Re:Heresy by solatic on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:33PM (#30984312)
If you are not trying to persuade the other person, if you are only trying to describe, as non-judgementally and as objectively as possible, some context or situation, then you can't offend anybody. This is an axiom of Nonviolent Communication.

If you do end up offending somebody, it's because you veered away from the objective and started to put your subjective viewpoint into it. If you're describing your subjective viewpoint to another person, you're either looking to persuade them or to feel better about yourself (i.e. seeking empathy).

Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:17PM (#30979968)
Not when evaluating truth. When evaluating speech.

Humans don't communicate by simply listing context-free facts at one another. Connotation, implication, and context all play a major role. The idea isn't that the words themselves become evil when said in a different context, but that we recognize that they do different things in different contexts.

Let's consider a totally different scenario: the justice system. In criminal cases, the standard of evidence is way higher than in civil cases. This is a recognition of the fact that the state is capable of causing far greater harm and it should hold itself to a higher standard. Nothing has changed about the truth of say, OJ Simpson's actions, that meant that he was found not guilty in a criminal trial but was able to be punished in a civil trial.

Similarly, we might recognize that somebody with a powerful voice and a large following has a greater responsibility to careful communication than the person working the counter at the local Starbucks.

Re:Heresy by Animats on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:38PM (#30980878)
That's what Graham did say:

"They know they're not supposed to ban ideas per se, so they have to recast the ideas as causing "harm," which sounds like something that can be banned."

Re:Heresy by kspacewalk2 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:53AM (#30978236)
> If PG wanted to stop getting pushback for approaching what society thinks is an acceptable line, he totally can, he just needs to rebrand and get out of the startup game.

No he doesn't. He can also opt to continue being exactly the brand that he is, remain firmly in the startup game, same push back against the self-appointed "social police", who only get away with their "policing" because people usually roll over.

Re:Heresy by Osmose on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:26PM (#30978630)
I mean, I agree that practically PG will never feel any serious repercussions for saying whatever he wants _because_ of his wealth and influence. I don't think that's healthy (as wealth and influence are often afforded to people due to privilege or luck instead of ability, wisdom, or empathy) but it is how the world is currently.

The cancel culture boogeyman generally doesn't destroy lives, which makes one wonder why people like PG feel it so important that they need to write essays decrying it.

Re:Heresy by teakettle42 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:29PM (#30978665)
> The cancel culture boogeyman generally doesn't destroy lives, which makes one wonder why people like PG feel it so important that they need to write essays decrying it.

Since only people with wealth and privilege are in a position to denounce it, they must have questionable ulterior motives?

You argue dishonestly and incoherently.

Re:Heresy by lc9er on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:07PM (#30979116)
Or more likely, they can’t believe mere mortals would dare push back against them.
Re:Heresy by alfor on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:41PM (#30978807)
You can test if it’s a boogeyman by saying something awful and true about a ’victim’ group at your job. For good measure you can also say something awful and true about white man.

See what is the response.

Re:Heresy by prepend on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:02PM (#30981124)
> The cancel culture boogeyman generally doesn't destroy lives, which makes one wonder why people like PG feel it so important that they need to write essays decrying it.

I don’t think that’s true as there are many examples of people’s loves being destroyed, mainly through careers ended. For example, Nobel-prize winning scientist Tim Hunt [0]. He’s famous and lost his job, for saying something stupid.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2015/6/11/8764901/tim-hunt-sexist-r...

Re:Heresy by zozbot234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:06PM (#30979105)
James Damore was a lowly software engineer and that did not save him from being canceled by the mob and losing his job. All the more outrageous because his working paper was an honest and forthright - and broadly accurate - response to an express request for feedback about how to improve working conditions. Shades of "let a thousand flowers bloom".
Re:Heresy by erikpukinskis on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:37PM (#30979494)
Is "honest and forthright" really the only qualification for working at Google?

What about being professional? Meaning... getting your work done in a way that you're not making other people hate you?

I can totally imagine a workplace where "It's not your problem if other people hate you" is the norm. And I'm happy for people who find an employer like that and enjoy that. But does every workplace need to be like that?

What's wrong with a workplace saying "you need to be clued in to how your colleagues are affected by you"?

For me, that's table stakes in being a profesional.

Re:Heresy by zozbot234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:40PM (#30979542)
> Meaning... getting your work done in a way that you're not making other people hate you?

"Making other people hate you"? Blaming a victim of vicious abuse for what his abusers were doing is very much not cool.

Re:Heresy by pessimizer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:00PM (#30981108)
I hope this is intentional satire, although I fear it's not. Reversing woke discourse to protect the people you approve of isn't anti-woke, it's just more orthodoxy policing.
Re:Heresy by derevaunseraun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:12PM (#30980611)
But they aren't abusers. How would you feel if you were a female SWE and had to work with someone who considers you "biologically inferior"? IMO Google did right by firing him
Re:Heresy by zozbot234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:21PM (#30980701)
> How would you feel if you were a female SWE and had to work with someone who considers you "biologically inferior"?

A good example of something Damore did not say. Even wrt. engineering skills in the narrowest sense, it's quite possible for women to meet the same standards as men; there will just be many fewer of them since a mixture of biological and cultural factors make for a significantly bigger pipeline on the male compared to the female side. Damore suggested ways to make the job more appealing to women and reduce this disparity.

Re:Heresy by derevaunseraun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:35PM (#30980846)
Interesting. Do you have a quote of where he said this?
Re:Heresy by rendall on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:42PM (#30980936)
Read his memo, carefully and charitably. He says it entirely throughout, and it is extremely clear.

Do you have a quote where he said women are biologically inferior? You do not, because he did not.

Re:Heresy by derevaunseraun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @07:36PM (#30982878)
"Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate"

"I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership."

And throughout the memo he keeps parroting this ridiculous line that women are more "neurotic" than men.

Sorry, but I'm incapable of reading something this insipid with a charitable eye

Re:Heresy by rendall on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:06PM (#30983430)
If you already believe he said women are biologically inferior, enough to throw quotes around it, you have a lot of work to do to unwind that bias. Most people would not be able to do it, especially if they are motivated reasoners.

I might respectfully suggest you try again.

If it will help you, he doesn't say women are more neurotic. What he says, truthfully, is that women on average score higher in neuroticism than men do in the Big 5 personality traits. It's a term in psychology with a specific meaning, it no doubt has a citation in his memo, and it has direct relevance to why there are fewer women in leadership roles. If the intent is to have more women in leadership roles, and this is true, it should be addressed, yeah? The memo suggests ways to do that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism

Apparently, this is a heresy: "The distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes."

Re:Heresy by derevaunseraun on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:01PM (#30983733)
I never said that he "said" that, I said he "considered" it. My evidence? Right here:

"Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate"

It doesn't matter whether he cites sources and tries to rationalize his position. He's in no place to be making these kinds of broad, overarching statements.

Re:Heresy by rendall on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:38AM (#30986154)
What does that mean to you? What do you think he's saying? Since you read the memo carefully and as charitably as you can, and not just scooped a quote from a news article about the memo, you will know that it's in the context of this bullet list:

> I strongly believe in gender and racial diversity, and I think we should strive for more. However, to achieve a more equal gender and race representation, Google has created several discriminatory practices:

> ● Programs, mentoring, and classes only for people with a certain gender or race [5] ● A high priority queue and special treatment for “diversity” candidates ● Hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate ● Reconsidering any set of people if it’s not “diverse” enough, but not showing that same scrutiny in the reverse direction (clear confirmation bias) ● Setting org level OKRs for increased representation which can incentivize illegal discrimination [6]

> These practices are based on false assumptions generated by our biases and can actually increase race and gender tensions. We’re told by senior leadership that what we’re doing is both the morally and economically correct thing to do, but without evidence this is just veiled left ideology that can irreparably harm Google.

> [5] Stretch, BOLD, CSSI, Engineering Practicum (to an extent), and several other Google funded internal and external programs are for people with a certain gender or race. > [6] Instead set Googlegeist OKRs, potentially for certain demographics. We can increase representation at an org level by either making it a better environment for certain groups (which would be seen in survey scores) or discriminating based on a protected status (which is illegal and I’ve seen it done). Increased representation OKRs can incentivize the latter and create zero-sum struggles between orgs.

I'll note, as you no doubt know from your reading of the memo, that your quote has a link that requires a google email to open. I'm not sure what it says.

If you read that carefully and charitably, without mindreading (he "considers" indeed), it reads like a political conservative, and not someone upset about "diversity hires" per se. You can disagree with him. I do, regarding affirmative action, but you cannot, given that quote, draw a conclusion that he thinks women are biologically inferior.

I'm not sure how "We can increase representation at an org level by making it a better environment for certain groups (which would be seen in survey scores)" squares with your notions about the memo.

Ok, I don't think any of that will change your mind about the memo or Damore, so feel free to have the last word.

Re:Heresy by ryanobjc on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:51PM (#30979659)
His paper was definitively broadly inaccurate. A number of dissections online have illustrated at how he grasps at evidence that doesn’t say what he claims it to say. He over emphasizes the nature of statistical evidence, and ignores the minimal strength of effect as well.

Besides which this wasn’t a “all of a sudden I wrote a paper and then I got fired” - he had been posting similar ideas into internal forums and was getting push back and disagreements. He got his editorial feedback already and he ignored it.

Re:Heresy by zozbot234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:03PM (#30979794)
Most of these "dissections" online simply omit his references, which gives a very misleading impression of the actual paper. Strength of effect is always minimal in psych and social science: you aren't going to find any seven-sigma results. So this is a biased criticism as well.
Re:Heresy by UncleMeat on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:22PM (#30980027)
Authors of papers he personally cited criticized his writeup as poor.
Re:Heresy by faichai on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:17PM (#30979244)
I mean, he didn’t say it, but this identity politics driven perspective is entirely the current thing wrong with the left. I say this as a moderate.

Rather than fall back on broad principles like free speech, you concoct evermore Byzantine rules about who can say what, given their race, gender, position of power or wealth. It’s unsustainable. It’s the Terror, but using cancellation rather than guillotine.

This approach doesn’t scale. In order to do as you say, everyone apparently needs to have a constantly updated internal graph, categorising people across an ever increasing number of categories and defining an ever number of allowable or disallowable viewpoints. It’s way too complex. It starts to sound like some kind of a psychosis.

A healthy principle, like Free Speech, espoused in a few words wins by being universally understandable. It just comes with a flip side that you will hear things that offend you. I think this is an OK price to pay.

Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:06PM (#30979835)
We just had 4 years of an identity politics Republican president (which party has totally succumbed to its idiotic, tribalist, identity-driven, populist base, discarding a lot of good conservative ideas and values in the process), so your spin on this as being "entirely the current thing wrong with the left" is disingenuous.

Dems are holding the line far better, though they too will fail, and the progressive wing will take over the party, and I'm personally not keen on that, even though I agree with them on some things.

Re:Heresy by faichai on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:30PM (#30980811)
The left has already gone too far, in my view.

From a free speech perspective the right seems to be more pro-principle and less identity-based cancellation hysteria, but they do so on the back of white, Christian nationalism and rampant hypocrisy which is a slightly different problem than heresy as per the original article.

Calling me disingenuous a bit of a reach.

Re:Heresy by pessimizer on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:03PM (#30981136)
> white, Christian nationalism

How could this possibly not be seen as identity politics?

Re:Heresy by ss108 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:18PM (#30981811)
...so you agree that the Republican Party has morphed into an outright White, Christian nationalist, identity-based party, but think that identity politics on the left is somehow worse?

I would say "disingenuous" is on point here.

Re:Heresy by faichai on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:54PM (#30982100)
I called the right a bunch of nationalist hypocrites!! I wasn’t trying to be kind to them, I agree they are doing identity politics too.

I am claiming that is the left that more prone to be cancelling people for heresy as per the original article. The right is more pernicious but there issues are different from a free speech/heresy perspective.

It’s OK for me to just use one side to make a point you know. I’m not the BBC.

Re:Heresy by pen2l on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:08PM (#30978425)
Is it a good thing that filters of all sorts are eradicated? Never before has a thought been able to travel as freely as it can now, 5 of the 8 billion people in the world have the internet, in a few seconds a thought you utter is potentially accessible to half of humanity. But this thought forgoes the chance to be interpreted, re-interpreted by mentors and participants in your community, your parents, peer-reviewed in some manner, honed, reconsidered before meeting the wider public.

Tech, reddit/fb/etc enables this in its propensity to reduce friction in the path of information's travel, to make sharing possible with the least amount of clicks and obstructions, this gives way to instinctive and emotional thinking over deliberate and logical thought, and indeed the proliferation of those thoughts. One would be remiss to look over the role that these new-fangled tools play in a discussion of these topics, particularly, the formalization of what constitutes as heresy and resulting actions of galvanized crowds or institutions when being met with heresy.

Re:Heresy by Turing_Machine on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:47PM (#30979626)
> If PG wanted to stop getting pushback for approaching what society thinks is an acceptable line

No one appointed you, or some random Twitter mob, to speak for "society".

Re:Heresy by jimkleiber on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:24PM (#30979331)
I read it as he wants pushback—that he wants to engage in a back and forth discussion, almost like two people in a fight pushing each other, not a fight where people push each other for a minute and then the other pulls out a gun. I understood his definition of heresy as a tool for wanting to end debate, not deepen it.
Re:Heresy by alanlammiman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:03PM (#30981691)
Well, to take the analogy a step further, if you go out on the street and start pushing people around, and one of them pulls out a baseball bat and beats you to a pulp, should you really complain that they didn't just push back? Nope. You just had it coming, and if you are such a macho street-fighter you should accept you got owned that time.

Sure, if you were in a dojo practicing martial arts - an environment that is safe where engagement has clear rules and often a judge - then it's a fair point to make. So if you are in a very specific context that is intended and structured for open and fair debate (e.g. a debate club), that's a fair argument.

That begs the question of whether a university is such a place. Undoubtedly some of it is. But I do not think all of the university, all of the time, is. Just as going into a gym and doing a judo throw on someone in the middle of their yoga class is not right, even if the gym has judo classes.

Re:Heresy by jimkleiber on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:13PM (#30983811)
I like how you took it further. I agree that there may be fewer rules in interacting outside of such a dojo, but there are still some rules. For example, laws governing self-defense that often say people cannot respond to a push by beating the person to a pulp with a bat, lest they get charged for assault and maybe more. And beyond law, just norms on how we agree people should or should not fight fairly.

So I think there is a spectrum from all rules to no rules and that most, if not all, places of human interaction have some level of formal and informal rules on how we expect others to behave.

Re:Heresy by alanlammiman on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:54PM (#30984058)
Indeed - I'm all for common sense and rules. So, whether you/the OP like it or not, the present 'formal and informal rules' of intellectual street-fighting do allow for the baseball bat of cancellation, rather than mere 'pushing-back', to be used against the 'push' of perceived prejudice. So if that is the 'push' one wants to make, better find an intellectual dojo that only allows pushing, not complain that your opponent didn't behave as you wanted them to.
Re:Heresy by jimkleiber on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:55AM (#30989663)
But how does one try to change the rules of a place without talking about them? Is the only answer to leave the place and find one where the rules already align?

I don't ask this facetiously, as I studied intercultural communication in college and have lived in a lot of places, often asking myself how much do I stay in a place and try to change the rules versus leaving to find a place where the rules already align with what I want.

Re:Heresy by pen2l on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:41PM (#30978804)
Test. (Please downvote me).
Re:Heresy by j-bos on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:54PM (#30978958)
Sorry, don't have enough points.
Re:Heresy by zozbot234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:46PM (#30978855)
Heresy! Burn the witch! /s