Re:The gambler's fallacy is not a fallacy?
by mac-chaffee on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:51PM
(#30974345)
Seems like a lot of the argument rests on "Steady, Switchy, Sticky" being the only possible options and their probabilities adding up to 1. That may seem to be a valid assumption because those correspond to all possible values of the chance of getting heads: greater than, less than, or equal to 50%.
But what about the chance that the "koin" is actually controlled by someone malicious? The liklihood of getting heads would have nothing to do with past events; it would just depend on how much money I bet and on which outcome. A paranoid gambler might easily assume this option is on the table.
Wouldn't that break the link between "<50%, =50%, >50%" and the concepts of "Steady-ness, Switchy-ness, Sticky-ness"? If so, can you conclude anything about the behavior of the koin since the probabilities of "Steady-ness, Switchy-ness, Sticky-ness" (as concepts) no longer add up to 1?
But what about the chance that the "koin" is actually controlled by someone malicious? The liklihood of getting heads would have nothing to do with past events; it would just depend on how much money I bet and on which outcome. A paranoid gambler might easily assume this option is on the table.
Wouldn't that break the link between "<50%, =50%, >50%" and the concepts of "Steady-ness, Switchy-ness, Sticky-ness"? If so, can you conclude anything about the behavior of the koin since the probabilities of "Steady-ness, Switchy-ness, Sticky-ness" (as concepts) no longer add up to 1?