Re:Do the Real Numbers Exist?
by sorokod on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:48PM
(#30971361)
The hypotenuse of a triangle with unit length sides is real enough.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Algebraic reals are the easy part, as are the few familiar classes of transcendentals that include numbers like pi and e. There’s only countably many of those. The set of all reals that can be described is countable. It’s the literally undescribable ones that are the problem, ontologically speaking
Ontologically speaking describing members of any uncountable set is a problem.
I assume you mean in the physical sense?
What if you get down to the quantum level? You don't have a straight line in the Euclidean sense any longer.
Yeah instead you have probability theory baked right in, real numbers and all!
You are conflating a mathematical model with reality, begging the question as it were.
Sure, otherwise you're just solipsistic, we have to assume things exist, it's how you make progress. If you think quantum is "the real stuff that exists" then you should assume, for now, that the model actually models something, and our best guess is that it's merely probability theory.
Do you question the existence of triangles and their mathematical properties?
Absolutely. There's no reason to believe space is Euclidean, in fact, relativity says it is curved. Quantum mechanics says that it is not infinitely divisible.
It depends what you mean by “existence”. Mathematical triangles are ideal conceptions that exist only in our minds.
Re:Do the Real Numbers Exist?
by marcosdumay on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:39PM
(#30972326)
Is it? Can you measure it? Do distances with arbitrary precision even exist?