Re:Horse-riding astronaut is a milestone in AI’s journey to ...
by oh_sigh on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:37PM
(#30960862)
If you ask for a nurse as an example, and 85% of nurses are female, shouldn't you expect it to give you a female?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Horse-riding astronaut is a milestone in AI’s journey to ...
by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:42PM
(#30961605)
If you ask for a nurse and 85% are female, but 95% of the nurse images online are female, what distribution do you want it to return? “What do you expect it to do” is a worse question than “What do you want it to do?”
It’s a problem is that right now there’s only one option (reflect the training set with a bias towards the most common cases).
Re:Horse-riding astronaut is a milestone in AI’s journey to ...
by karpierz on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:43PM
(#30961614)
It depends on whether you want it to show what someone would expect a nurse to look like, or show what a nurse. Nothing in the definition of a nurse implies female.
If you ask for a female US president, should the application simply return a black screen?
If you ask for a black US president, would you expect it to only ever return pictures of Barack Obama?
Re:Horse-riding astronaut is a milestone in AI’s journey to ...
by oh_sigh on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:32PM
(#30962177)
I agree nothing in the definition of nurse implies female, but something in our culture definitely has "nurse -> female". Likewise, nothing in "college student" definitionally implies age, but I wouldn't consider it a success if my system displayed a picture of a 9 year old.
Re:Horse-riding astronaut is a milestone in AI’s journey to ...
by lovemenot on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:12AM
(#30965846)
>> Nothing in the definition of a nurse implies female.
Unfortunately it's not a great example with which to make this point. Before Florence Nightingale, a nurse was a person who was employed to suckle your babies. Of course 100% were female.
Wet nurse was a later coining to differentiate the two meanings.