The taxes to pay for the UBI will generally come from the middle and higher income households; who are already spending the money they need to on those items. Losing some of their money to taxes won't do much to reduce the amount they spend on those.
However, the lower income segment, where UBI will have a much higher impact, will start spending a lot more on these items. Because, in theory, they were not spending as much as they would want to on them previously (bad housing, cheap food, etc.. could be improved).
As such, the demand for those "survival" items could increase a fair amount, causing the prices for them to increase. If you consider this inflation (which I would, since it's a rise in prices for things that matter), then there would likely be inflation.
The land tax will put the land to best use, and that will drive up the supply of housing units, which means the cost to rent will go down. All of this while the average person sees lower tax rates and the person who sits on an empty lot sees much higher tax rates. The money available to collect from NYC and SF land taxes alone could fund a nation-wide UBI.
To do that, an LVT would have to be calibrated so that it was enough to bring the market price of unimproved land to zero, plus (or minus, in certain market conditions) an additional amount needed compensate for dynamic supply and demand effects (lots of people wanting to move in plus building lag driving prices up above expected long-term equilibrium, lots of people moving out doing the opposite.)
> The land tax will put the land to best use,
Perhaps, but if so...
> and that will drive up the supply of housing units
...then not if housing units aren't the most profitable use of land in the local area it won't.
> All of this while the average person sees lower tax rates
Confiscatory (and the level of LVT you suggest is exactly that) taxes on land don't reduce tax rates for the average person in a country with a nearly 65% pre-policy homeownership rate.
> The money available to collect from NYC and SF land taxes alone could fund a nation-wide UBI.
No, even if that were true pre-policy it couldn't after you enacted it, because you are ignoring dynamic effects. Confiscatory taxation on land will catastrophically drive down land value.
Yep!
> dynamic supply and demand effects
Yep!
> ...then not if housing units aren't the most profitable use of land in the local area it won't.
Agree. But they almost always are.
> Confiscatory
Housing can either be an investment or it can be affordable long-term, it can not be both. Therefore the Land Value Tax is the only correct rate. And a UBI for at least a decent portion of it nullifies any potential regressive nature of it.
> don't reduce tax rates for the average person
It does, over time, as housing supply improves and the entire economy gets out of the mud. The wealthy own the most expensive land.
> catastrophically drive down land value
The tax is based on the rental value of the land, that is, the flow. You could see it as the neutralization of the capture of the positive externalities of your neighbors.
As in your first example where an empty lot will settle at $0 market price, that would not mean it has a $0 tax. It would still have whatever tax it would have. You determine that tax based on market rates, and it is a set cost based on that particular property - it's not some percentage of the market rates as we do today.
I agree that in the short-term, with most people having most of their networth in their home, this would be a bad thing. We can transition to this process slowly, and only increase as the incentives improve the economy and allow us to improve. The best way to start is to have a net zero change where we remove taxes on improvements and instead to tax the land.
Making better use of the city land would in fact drive the overall land flow value up hugely in value. SF has much more room to improve than NYC, NYC makes pretty good use of it's land. But so can CT and NJ, and the rise in supply of non-NYC land outside of NYC will drive more value into NYC.
While this is one of the most often cut&pasted comments on HN, I haven't seen a thorough discussion of what it actually means in practice.
Any references with substantial analysis of proposals to achieve this and what the unintended consequences could be?
You seem to advocating for an immense increase in property taxes. This line from the previous comment:
> The money available to collect from NYC and SF land taxes alone could fund a nation-wide UBI.
suggests that the increase in taxes would be quite enourmous indeed.
That would certainly make housing a bad investment. Nobody would want to own any if the recurring property taxes are that high.
But of course it doesn't make property affordable either, if the tax rates are sky high.
The best introductions are Lars excellent book and blog articles[1] over on Scott Alexander's blog.
> Nobody would want to own any if the recurring property taxes are that high. But of course it doesn't make property affordable either, if the tax rates are sky high.
The tax rates are set by the market, so they are by definition affordable. You are taxed on the land alone, what capital you put on top of it is entirely yours to earn.
[0]: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/3/6/non-glamorous-g...
[1]: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/does-georgism-work-is-...
Demand steadily increases over time, a UBI would cause a spike in that demand so there would be inflation at a higher rate while the market stabilizes. Without an increase in the rate the money is devalued this inflation should stabilize. The problems come when we devalue our money at the same time we're increasing demand causing changes at a rate faster than the markets can compensate.
UBI is a shotgun approach and a political tactic rather than a real plan for helping those who need it. A negative income tax and other options that target this help where it's needed would be better options. either way though the trick is to get money where its needed without increasing debt or the money supply while doing so at a rate that doesn't shock the system.
No matter what you do here you're increasing the demand for goods. Without an increase in the total money supply that would stabilize but there would still be some inflation because of it.