Re:Ability to see expertise is a milestone worth aiming for
by hef19898 on Thursday April 07, 2022 @05:09AM
(#30942272)
I'd have to look up the book again, which is sitting in a shelf somewhere at home, about knowledge management. In there, if memory serves well, someone says that people who achieved true mastery of a something look like they have no clue whatsoever about said topic. I always understood that in the sense that those people are beyond talking about formalisms (usually the hallmark of "expert", just throw abbreviations and lingo around) and know to a high degree of certainty what they don't know.
That being said, I did train /teach supply chain management before in my life. And that showed me that being good in a subject has nothing to do with teaching that subject.
EDIT: After having read the essay beginning to end, I'd like to add one more observation: If you are new to a situation and discuss it with the resident expert, you can measure your level of mastery if that discussion of some serious potential challenges end with you, the new guy, saying "Fuck". And the resident expert responds with a slight smile and a nod. Usually, following this revelation that you now have a peer realizing the same issues, the really productive work can start. I love those moments, not the least because they are so damn rare.
That being said, I did train /teach supply chain management before in my life. And that showed me that being good in a subject has nothing to do with teaching that subject.
EDIT: After having read the essay beginning to end, I'd like to add one more observation: If you are new to a situation and discuss it with the resident expert, you can measure your level of mastery if that discussion of some serious potential challenges end with you, the new guy, saying "Fuck". And the resident expert responds with a slight smile and a nod. Usually, following this revelation that you now have a peer realizing the same issues, the really productive work can start. I love those moments, not the least because they are so damn rare.