News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by bennyp101 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @08:32AM (#30931288)
"you can have a full fledged IDE with 0 fiddling" - that is 100% not a thing that has ever happened to me whenever I go and look at emacs/vim!

Modal editing is not really something that is needed anymore, and a lot of people don't have time to learn a new language just to move about in their IDE - just click the mouse button ...

Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by epicide on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @10:28AM (#30932343)
I agree that neither vim nor emacs are "0 fiddling" [0]. However,

> Modal editing is not really something that is needed anymore

Honestly, I'm not sure it was ever "needed", but that's not really the point IMO.

It's hard for me to think about editing text in any way other than how Vim handles it. Part of that is admittedly just familiarity, but I think there's also something to the idea of treating strings as more than just arrays of characters. Once you start thinking about your text and code as nouns of various sizes and granularity [0], losing those feels cumbersome.

In order to achieve the latter, you either need modality or a huge number of control hotkeys. Vim takes the former approach while Emacs (and IDEs) takes the latter.

So yes, you can achieve the "crowning feature" of Vim (IMO) without modality, but I don't see modality itself as being a pro or a con as much as a design choice. If you don't prefer it, more power to you.

> and a lot of people don't have time to learn a new language just to move about in their IDE - just click the mouse button ...

This also works the other way. I don't want to have to learn where all the buttons are in $IDE just to move my text about. Thankfully, many IDEs include a Vim mode or plugin for it, but those are never quite the same.

Every tool has some level of learning curve. If you want it to be more flexible, powerful, and to get the most out of it, that learning curve is gonna be steeper. That goes for both IDEs with their buttons and Vim with its modal commands.

For something that you might use for hours on end every single day for professional work, putting in some time to learn it pays dividends. For both Vim and IDEs.

[0]: In vim parlance, this is effectively what "movements" operate on. They sort of define these objects via implication.

Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by rayiner on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @08:35AM (#30931306)
Emacs isn’t a modal editor!
Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by bennyp101 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @12:21PM (#30934038)
That's true, my bad. I've just only ever used it with evil (I find the chords even harder to remember!)
Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by cjbgkagh on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @10:37AM (#30932454)
I refer to it as a chorded editor. Of course there is viper mode.
Re:What’s new in Emacs 28.1? by youerbt on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @10:13AM (#30932142)
As long as your input device is optimized for inserting text (and your keyboard certainly is) modal editing is surely something desirable for programming.