Re:Google is Doping the Horses
by cupcake_death on Monday October 10, 2011 @06:02AM
(#3093085)
We, (http://www.explore.to) recently were penalized by Google for having thin content. That is, we have business profiles that are yet to be claimed and enriched by business owners, (As do lots of Google Places listings, (That appear above the fold)). Yet, thin content via Google's own properties is fine? http://www.google.com/search?q=Mark+Zuckerberg&pws=0&...
Zuckerbergs profile is adding nothing to the Google users experience, except for visibility of G+.
as buro9 said, the interesting questions have nothing to do with the (stupid) doped horse analogy or whether this upsets some platonic ideal of a page-ranked search index (in reality, they don't exist and no one would want to use one).
the interesting questions are if google including this information is harming competitors that would bring innovation to the market, whether that's even a bad thing, long term, and if (somehow) preventing google from including this would just hobble a mostly good product or would actually materially improve things for consumers.
those are really hard questions, and asking them like this just diminishes the level of debate that can be had about them.