Re:Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors
by UncleMeat on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @05:34PM
(#30925329)
Yep. Every discussion I've ever had with a "free speech absolutist" has gone like this.
"What are your thoughts on false advertising laws?"
"That's fine, because fraud is a crime and therefore not speech"
People have bucketed "things I think should be legal" as "speech" and "things I think should be illegal" as "not speech" and then this makes it trivial to say that all speech should be legal because the definition is circular.
Re:Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors
by OrvalWintermute on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:40PM
(#30923088)
> Everyone is a “free speech exceptionist”, it’s just varying degrees of exceptions
++
Exceptions for me, but not for thee!
Because it’s just a catchy phrase that sounds good on paper.
What’s a “free speech absolutist” position on spam, NDAs, calls to violence, libel, national security, fraud, false advertising, copyright infringement, personal privacy, etc.?
I don’t know of any country, platform or person that follows an “absolutist” philosophy on free speech within any reasonable definition of the word “absolute”.
Everyone is a “free speech exceptionist”, it’s just varying degrees of exceptions.