News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oberlin Colleges loses appeal in suit filed by local bakery by tetromino_ on Monday April 04, 2022 @10:50AM (#30907314)
> Jeffrey Sachs, a political science professor at Acadia University who often writes about free speech on campus, offered a similar opinion in a Twitter thread. He noted that the suit hinged on two actions: the libelous fliers distributed by staff and the Student Senate resolution.

> “It’s the second action that really worries me. Basically, the court held that since Oberlin authorizes the student senate, subsidizes it, provides a supervisor, and allows it to post its documents on school property, it is legally responsible for the student senate’s speech,” Sachs tweeted.

> While Sachs notes the dean erred in handing out the fliers, “the senate resolution issue feels much more complicated and nothing to celebrate.” The ruling, he suggests, implies that colleges must scrutinize the speech they provide a platform for and “have a legal duty to censor.”

Isn't the solution to clarify that the student senate is not an official body of the college and that its views do not represent the college's views? Require a disclaimer at the bottom of every student senate email, ask the senate to find its own funding, and the college ought to be in a much more defensible position legally. And as a side effect, a student senate which is financially and organizationally independent of the college will be a much better venue for real student free speech.

Re:Oberlin Colleges loses appeal in suit filed by local bakery by AlanYx on Monday April 04, 2022 @12:10PM (#30908313)
> Isn't the solution to clarify that the student senate is not an official body of the college and that its views do not represent the college's views

I don't even think that's necessary. Sachs is leaving out a lot of the context/facts in this case... my understanding is that what made the university liable for the student senate's actions is that the university administration started endorsing the position taken by the senate in various ways, for example by suspending business with the bakery in response to the senate's resolution.

Re:Oberlin Colleges loses appeal in suit filed by local bakery by tannedNerd on Monday April 04, 2022 @12:57PM (#30908986)
Yup the issue at stake isn't the fact that the student body senate put out those statements, it's that school administrators endorsed them and acted upon them. If the student senate had passed the resolution but Oberlin had not canceled contracts without compensation and admins hadn't handed out flyers there would be no case.
Re:Oberlin Colleges loses appeal in suit filed by local bakery by HelloNurse on Monday April 04, 2022 @11:09AM (#30907542)
A student "senate" is necessarily official. Unofficial replacements should be, at minimum, multiple competing student unions.
Re:Oberlin Colleges loses appeal in suit filed by local bakery by hedora on Monday April 04, 2022 @12:27PM (#30908541)
I don't think any solution involving spamming legal disclaimers is a good one.