Re:Overtone
by samaaron on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:00PM
(#3089303)
I practiced writing that code for about a day before I could write it flawlessly in one take. I guess, in a similar fashion to how a musician will practice using an instrument before going on stage.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
And in a similar fashion, after a musician/coder practices enough, improvisation will come naturally. Thanks again for putting this together.
Re:Overtone
by stygianguest on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:10PM
(#3089330)
That only holds for some kinds of playing. How is your experience with improvisation? Can you manage quick changes? Or does it always tend to be a slow buildup of rythms harmonics and melodies?
Re:Overtone
by swannodette on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:58PM
(#3089534)
Improvisation requires plenty of practice - http://www.amazon.com/Improvisation-Its-Nature-Practice-Musi...
Re:Overtone
by stygianguest on Monday October 10, 2011 @04:35AM
(#3092869)
Apparently my question is not clear. I'm asking this as a musician who does a lot of improvisation. The question is wether livecode improvisation is comparable.
The most enjoyable thing in improvisation, are sudden changes that can emerge in a good session. You typically have less than a second to react to such things. That is, less than a second to change rythm/feel, tempo, harmonics, volume, etc. More often than not all at the same time. Playing like that makes you feel part of the organism from which the music emerges, rather than a thinking actor in a rehearsed play. A feeling that I only find in dancing and other things I do with my wife.
I would really like to get into this livecoding stuff, and have tried ChuCK and SuperCollider. Clearly I never practiced enough to improvise in the live, but I'm wondering if it is at all possible in the sense I described above.