News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by velocicopter on Saturday October 08, 2011 @04:24PM (#3088818)
The moment we make a robot capable of reliably fetching a sandwich it will no longer be ethical for us to order it around (at least, not without paying a salary).
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by code_duck on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:46PM (#3088999)
Why would the robot need a salary? So it can buy afford robot entertainment on the weekends?
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by philh on Saturday October 08, 2011 @06:35PM (#3089083)
It wouldn't necessarily be a money-salary.

But to be precise: at that point, it will no longer be ethical for us to order it around. We will have to resort to asking politely or to bargaining, such as giving it some form of salary in exchange for fetching sandwiches.

Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by felipemnoa on Saturday October 08, 2011 @07:24PM (#3089159)
That is rich. Robots will be tools, nothing more. Until a bug in their hardware or software causes them to rebel, of course.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by velocicopter on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:11PM (#3089334)
Tools can't reliably fetch sandwiches:

'My usual.' or 'ham salad, easy on the mayo.'

Then the robot has to cross the street, queue at the sandwich store, discover that they're fresh out of mayo, or whatever, and has to decide what to do next. Should it contact you for new instructions, take the initiative and visit a different place, buy ingredients and prepare a snack personally, or any other of countless possibilities? Any of which may involve handling new, unanticipated phenomena.

Thus fetching a sandwich, reliably, is a creative task, and any entity capable of doing it has achieved human status.

Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by reledi on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:43PM (#3089503)
> Thus fetching a sandwich, reliably, is a creative task, and any entity capable of doing it has achieved human status.

Robots in Futurama are near human status. Real robots (including the one you described) are not. Fetching a sandwich as a robot is an algorithmic task.

Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by icebraining on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:00PM (#3089427)
The programmer will write an algorithm which is capable of generating a fitness function for each action based on its current goal(s). Then it'll decide what to do based on the action with the best fitness value.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by AretNCarlsen on Saturday October 08, 2011 @11:16PM (#3089571)
Just like I do when I want a sandwich.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by ars on Saturday October 08, 2011 @11:51PM (#3089622)
Except you wrote your own fitness function, it wasn't written for you.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by code_duck on Monday October 10, 2011 @04:14PM (#3095595)
Fetching a sandwich means nothing. Deciding to fetch a sandwich because I'm hungry, seem stressed and the robot likes me... but won't get a sandwich for my coworker, because he's a jerk - then it may be time for compensation. The robot still is not likely to need a salary anymore than a horse needs a salary, however.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by rohern on Saturday October 08, 2011 @07:42PM (#3089179)
First time I've heard etiquette equated with ethics.
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by bdonlan on Saturday October 08, 2011 @11:46PM (#3089611)
What if the robot really enjoys fetching sandwiches? Sure, that may be because we programmed it to enjoy (experience a high fitness value for) obeying orders, but once we've created such a being, do we not have an ethical obligation to order it around, so that it can feel enjoyment?

Why should we go out of our way to build robots with similar ideas of what is pleasurable to us?

Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by philh on Sunday October 09, 2011 @07:27AM (#3090265)
To me, "ordering it around" implies the threat of negative consequences if it refuses. If it really enjoys fetching sandwiches, there's no reason we shouldn't ask it to; but if it decides for whatever reason that it doesn't want to fetch sandwiches even though it really enjoys doing so, we can't say "fetch me that sandwich or I'll activate your disutility circuits".
Re:Robot: I Now Have Common Sense. Engineer: Great, Go Fetch... by mannicken on Sunday October 09, 2011 @04:44AM (#3090039)
What if you programmed a human to enjoy finding sandwiches?

Well, now that you think of it we are all in a way programmed to enjoy certain things through classical conditioning.