News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pre-orders are scams according to Paypal by dangrossman on Saturday October 08, 2011 @02:41PM (#3088608)
> They've made it incredibly clear that their policies and actions are arbitrary and they don't care about their customers at all.

It seems to me that they're incredibly consistent and care about their customers exactly as much as any other merchant account provider. This exact story with a game developer taking preorders then having PayPal problems has played out a half dozen times on Hacker News alone; in reality it happens regularly. It would happen if these developers applied for a merchant account and said they were taking long-term preorders on the application too.

The only problem with PayPal is that merchants don't expect PayPal to act like every other processor, and have no experience dealing with the risk/underwriting departments of banks to realize that what they're doing would be a problem anywhere.

As far as why businesses still use PayPal? Nobody else operates in as many countries. Nobody else has over 200 million members already signed up and trusting the payment process. Few MOTO merchant accounts actually beat the fees PayPal charges, especially once you have >$10,000/mo in volume, when you actually add up all the transaction fees. And few gateways are as easy to implement or built into as many other ecommerce products.

It makes no sense from a business standpoint not to use PayPal (which in 2011 does not mean sending someone to paypal.com to pay if they want to pay on site). They're cheaperc, more reliable, allow you to accept all major credit and debit cards, bank transfers, eChecks, payments from 200+ million members' balances, and pay you your funds immediately. If you're that worried about having a problem, have a backup in place to switch to and don't hold a PayPal balance -- risk free.

You would think the HN community would look at PayPal and see a success story to be shared and celebrated. They were the only significant 3rd party payment processor to make it through the dot com bubble. There have been many attempts. They all went out of business due to fraud. PayPal was bleeding over $10 million a month to chargebacks and fraud at one point. They created the software and systems to make a global 3rd party payment platform possible and survived. Now they make possible an enormous amount of ecommerce for tens of millions of people that would not be able to accept payments any other way.

Instead we see the occasional "horror story" that would likely happen whether the developer was using PayPal or anyone else, and a PayPal Sucks website that's accumulated barely 2000 threads in over a decade (what fraction of a fraction of a percent of PayPal users is that?), and certain vocal people pile on the "why would anyone ever use PayPal" bandwagon...

Re:Pre-orders are scams according to Paypal by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 08, 2011 @08:38PM (#3089265)
To add to this, there is a false perception of paypal's actions due to excessive visibility of one half of the equation. Paypal has to deal with fraud, phishing, money laundering, international organized crime, etc. Overwhelmingly every aspect of that is hidden from the public. No fraudster is going to make a post on reddit of how paypal shut them down. And paypal isn't going to publicize it because of legal issues. So all we have are these little glimpses of people who have no experience with merchant accounts being affected by these anti-fraud policies and everyone sympathizes because somehow it's become normal to assume that worldwide digital money transfers should be hassle-free and inexpensive.

Paypal isn't perfect, but the biggest reason why so many people are upset with it is because there isn't a suitable substitute.

Re:Pre-orders are scams according to Paypal by Terretta on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:56PM (#3089417)
> They were the only significant 3rd party payment processor to make it through the dot com bubble.

Not so. We were processing millions of transactions for virtual goods (streaming ppv) before, during, and after the bubble, and balanced among multiple processors to handle the spikes. We didn't have to change any out, and were using several of the largest.

Granted, some of the best, like Payflow, got gobbled by Verisign then Paypal, but the APIs generally stayed the same, and are still worth using today.

But today you also have cheaper options by going up the food chain, like direct to FDMS.

Re:Pre-orders are scams according to Paypal by bluelu on Sunday October 09, 2011 @04:50AM (#3090050)
Well said.

Some people think they can collect hundreds of thounsands of euros by just providing an email and a name to Paypal. Then they wonder when their funds get freezed (see minecraft) and then thy complain that they have to provide ID to get their funds released.