News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by 0x12 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:14AM (#3087541)
That's quite a story and I wasn't aware of it. I'm quite surprised by the following passage:

"Jobs never did a lick of engineering in his life. He had me snowed," Alcorn later recalled. "It took years before I figured out that he was getting Woz to 'come in the back door' and do all the work while he got the credit."

Jobs convinced Wozniak to work on the game during his day job at Hewlett-Packard, when he was meant to be designing calculators. At night the two would collaborate on building it at Atari: Wozniak as engineer, Jobs as breadboarder and tester.

Allegedly, Jobs told Wozniak that he could have half of a $700 bounty if they were able to get the chip count under 50 (typical games of the day tended to require around 100 chips). After four sleepless days that gave both of them a case of mono (an artificial time limit, it turns out: Jobs had a plane to catch, Atari wasn't in that much of a rush), the brilliantly gifted Wozniak delivered a working board with just 46 chips.

Jobs made good on his promise and gave Wozniak his promised $350. What he didn't tell him -- and what Wozniak didn't find out until several years later -- was that Jobs also pocketed a bonus somewhere in the neighborhood of $5,000. Though it's often reported that this caused a rift in their friendship, Wozniak seems to have no hard feelings."

This doesn't diminish Steve Jobs for me (maybe it should, but he was what he was and it's ancient history anyway), but it definitely enhances Steve Wozniak's stature.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by gjm11 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:37AM (#3087571)
It should probably diminish Steve Jobs, but not in quite the obvious way.

Not: "SJ did that, and it was bad, so I think worse of him."

But: "SJ did that, which shows that he was unusually willing and able to take the credit and the benefits of someone else's work; so my estimate of the share of the credit and benefits he got later in his career should accordingly be reduced."

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by sjs on Saturday October 08, 2011 @12:02PM (#3088197)
In the last 20 years or so Steve Jobs often deflected praise from himself to the teams who worked on products. I have never seen him take any personal credit for any product he has introduced or discussed and always uses terms like "we", e.g. "I'm really excited to show you what we made."

Without excusing his behaviour I'd like to remind people here that perhaps we have all acted selfishly or done things we are not proud of when we were younger (high school or college aged).

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by adrianwaj on Saturday October 08, 2011 @01:58PM (#3088483)
Did SJ actually bring people up on stage with him, and name them, and point out their roles? How generous was he in this respect?
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by robterrell on Saturday October 08, 2011 @03:27PM (#3088709)
I'd say this was fairly generous, and I've never heard of it repeated by any other technology company:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Apple_Mac...

Even Jef Raskin's signature is in there, for crying out loud, and Jobs stole the Mac team from him.

But to your general point, have you ever seen a product intro where the entire team is brought up and named one by one? It seems like you're holding Jobs to an arbitrarily high standard.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by leoc on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:03PM (#3089432)
But he went off the idea of crediting individuals at some point after the release of the Macintosh, at least in part for fairly understandable reasons. http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story...
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by adrianwaj on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:37PM (#3088983)
Thanks for answering.. I mainly bring it up because of this line: "Good artists copy great artists steal" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CW0DUg63lqU
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by ugh on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:07PM (#3089436)
Certainly. Quite often actually.

Especially during the last years it were, for example, often the leading engineers themselves who demoed their software.

In his public appearances I followed (all post-2000) I never ever had the feeling that he was taking undue credit, I never really had the feeling that he was taking credit at all. I can’t recall any instance where he presented something as his great idea, it was always “we”, never “I”. He didn’t always specifically thank everyone who worked on the products they presented but quite often. (You know, that whole routine where he asks all the people from Apple in the audience to stand up – didn’t always happen, but sometimes.)

I’m not sure whether it makes a lot of sense to judge the 2000s Jobs based on the 70s and 80s Jobs. Humans do a lot of dumb stuff in their lives. But humans also change.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by thaumaturgy on Saturday October 08, 2011 @02:14PM (#3088525)
Does the orchestra bow with the conductor?
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by adrianwaj on Saturday October 08, 2011 @06:03PM (#3089033)
SJ to me was a conductor, and an arranger and product visionary but a not a full bore composer, inventor or engineer on Mozart's level: more a Scott McNealy with design sense. I never met him, so I don't know how inspired he was in person.

The best way I can sum it up, is that Apple may have been evolutionary, but not revolutionary, even though for many people owning one of their products was a revolution. Did Apple invent or just popularize the GUI? Was SJ more a popularizer or more an inventor?

This is McNealy's take on Apple and SJ:

"Apple is beyond proprietary, and the consumer has no idea that they are checking into the roach motel. Jobs has been brilliant, and he also understands the power of the secret better than anyone I have every seen." (3/10)

http://mobile.informationweek.com/10244/show/e0e978f8df83663...

-- the conductor bows to audience with orchestra, and applauds orchestra as well.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by leoc on Saturday October 08, 2011 @08:54PM (#3089290)
The conductor is invariably expected to invite the orchestra to stand and take a bow after taking his own, if I recall correctly.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by rquantz on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:51AM (#3089693)
Additionally, the conductor frequently asks individual members of the orchestra to stand -- section leaders, anyone who had a solo, etc. -- or asks sections to stand together if they had a particularly prominent role.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by dasil003 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @03:56PM (#3088756)
Right, because no one's character ever evolves after the age of 20.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by div on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:59AM (#3087590)
Almost every time I read a story about the two Steves, it feels like their relationship was unbalanced. Woz always comes out as the brilliant engineer who gets played by management to lay golden eggs for nearly free.

I haven't read iWoz, and I doubt Woz himself feels this way about it, but these stories just have a way of coming across that way.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by enjo on Saturday October 08, 2011 @06:11AM (#3087603)
I think that's part of Woz's mystique. He's the brilliant hacker who just likes solving problems. It fits in with the story that Woz originally offered the Apple 1 to Hewlett Packard as he thought they should have first crack at it.... that's just who he is.

I think he's just fine being seen that way:)

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by danmaz74 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:33AM (#3087878)
AFAIK, Woz had to offer the Apple 1 to HP first because of contractual obligations...
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by 0x12 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:46AM (#3087908)
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by city41 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:27AM (#3087863)
After reading iWoz, I both felt sorry and impressed by Woz at the same time. He's got a very interesting outlook on life.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by mikeash on Saturday October 08, 2011 @03:05PM (#3088663)
Woz is worth $100 million, as far as I know all due to his role in Apple, despite not having done any work for the company in about 25 years. I'd say that's pretty far from "nearly free". He may well have gotten shafted a few times, but the end result seems to have come out well.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by s3graham on Saturday October 08, 2011 @12:45PM (#3088312)
I expect that, monetarily, things worked out just fine for him.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by techdmn on Saturday October 08, 2011 @08:40AM (#3087786)
It makes me think less of him, the guy screwed his best friend. In the same way there's a story about Gates refusing to pay the secretaries overtime when Microsoft was getting started.[1] Somehow that bothers me more than all the anti-trust stuff later. (Possibly due to similar personal experience.)

[1] http://books.google.com/books?id=XdYOGBhp0SAC&lpg=PA163&...

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by technoslut on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:52AM (#3087921)
>It makes me think less of him, the guy screwed his best friend.

None of these people are saints. At the time Jobs was essentially a kid. If you dig deep on any person you will find things that will disappoint you. We are human and destined to be flawed. One, or even a few moments, do not sum up a man's life. You must take it in its entirety. Even then, you have to also understand that every decision or path we take will define us, one way or the other.

Ask yourself, is there an Apple without Jobs or Woz? If no, then they were mutually beneficial to each other. In the end both Woz and Jobs have come out with a more significant life than if they had never met.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by 0x12 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:10AM (#3087947)
Nobody has to be a saint, but there is something very uncomfortable about putting one over on a friend like that.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by mechanical_fish on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:23AM (#3087974)
There are lots of stories about Woz and Jobs that make me uncomfortable. But that's not surprising: They were big fans of practical jokes, and I was never much of a fan myself.

Woz seems to be able to think of this story in the spirit of a practical joke.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by technoslut on Saturday October 08, 2011 @10:34AM (#3087998)
It is, as you put it, uncomfortable. This goes to other things that Jobs has done as well in his youth. If I was to put the magnifying lens under your life, or anyone else's, I can assure you I would find things you don't want to be seen. No one is perfect. The best we can do is make the world a better place than it was before. I believe that both Jobs and Woz did that.

If you don't like what he has done then be a better person. Learn from his mistakes, as well as the triumphs, and pay it forward. Jobs is a hero to many but he is not worthy of worship.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by cubicle67 on Saturday October 08, 2011 @05:53AM (#3087581)
You really need to read iWoz, his biography. It's got a heap of similarly great stories and is told in Woz' characteristic humble way
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by 16s on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:18AM (#3087842)
Woz seemed to take it really well. He said that he didn’t care about the money and would have done it for free. Steve was nice to him and Woz was having fun. Some might say that Steve took advantage of Woz (and that's probably true) but all in all they got along.
Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by noonespecial on Saturday October 08, 2011 @08:25PM (#3089241)
Every one who's ever treated me (or others I've been around) this way has failed miserably, mostly due to this type of character flaw.

What this says to me is that Steve grew out of this just in time and with a little luck and a lot of self improvement, became better. Good on him.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by Someone on Saturday October 08, 2011 @01:21PM (#3088375)
"but it definitely enhances Steve Wozniak's stature."

Because he worked on a side project during working hours at HP?

This is far from an ethical high point for Jobs, but Woz, too, does not come over as a saint.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by keenerd on Saturday October 08, 2011 @01:49PM (#3088459)
And the firing squad for jaywalkers!

Seriously though, this is something probably the majority of HNers do. Those in the minority probably used to, but got burned when the higher ups found out and either fired them or appropriated the tech.

Re:"He offered the Apple II to Atari... we said no. No thank... by CamperBob on Saturday October 08, 2011 @03:34PM (#3088724)
You need to educate yourself about the HP Way before saying something like that.

Hewlett and Packard explicitly wanted their company to serve as a springboard for local talent.