Ah... Good, Old-Fashioned Organic Agriculture.
There's a huge power in knowledge consensus. It's got all kinds of flaws, but it meanders generally in a growth direction, and that's better than any other prediction system I'm familiar with.
What you instead want to look for is:
"MANY people who are familiar with magic boxes tried to make this guy's magic box and couldn't replicate his method."
You are looking for valid contradiction to stated facts to invalidate claims, not for a widespread consensus on the claims.
This is important because, as a single example, two people can use different methods to achieve the same outcome based on their own respective theories that have minor flaws but present strong evidence that they are in their entirety true. It is only by reconciling & finding the contradictions between the two that you can come out with a single VALID theory.
If I were a scientist I would probably have some examples of this occurring in the past, but off the top of my head I would suggest it is improbably that there has never been a situation where two competing theories that each had strong evidence were both eliminated in favor of a single unified theory that reconciled differences between them.
There is no room for laypeople in scientific disagreement.
This also has a reasonable take-away: sometimes lighting an altar on fire can be faked even when it looks real. Or, "beware the flashy demo". Fusion and especially some of the more shameless corners of AI come to mind.
My apologies if this stretches the analogy too far.
Alexa, set room temperature to 28°C!
> I have the same opinion of academics - show me what you can light on fire.
I don't know if you're going to be welcome in a lot of liberal art colleges, since this is the ending(SPOILERS!):
> And Elijah said to them, “Seize the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape.” And they seized them. And Elijah brought them down to the brook Kishon and slaughtered them there.
I suppose that’s an early instance of p-hacking.
“Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.” - Hebrews 11:1 (ESV)
Belief is not a synonym for faith.
(That didn’t turn out to be a good definition, but not because of the “belief” part.)
Faith implies belief without requiring any evidence. But belief can be conditional on evidence.
It's not fatted calves, but we do sacrifice some money to the quantum folks so they can break our enemies' encryption locks ... in like 25 years ...
Most people will never understand the direct evidence of even relatively mundane science, and almost everyone is incapable of understanding the direct evidence of the cutting edge.[0] and its implications, ergo in lieu of understanding they must substitute belief. Where science policy/communication fails here is in producing a 'believable' system, with adequate consistency and storytelling for persons who will only ever understand by analogy.
[0]Regular people don't know what an integral is. The intelligent, educated, and motivated don't have the bandwidth to really understand more than a smattering topics deeply.
Belief can be informed by evidence or not. It simply means acceptance or confidence that something is true. You can have faith in the available evidence, or faith in the absence of evidence.
(*Or “convincing evidence.”)
Those with faith have proof or evidence that can be used to demonstrate or to back up that faith. It's not blind.
I have the same opinion of academics - show me what you can light on fire. For example, I don't believe in physics because it makes intuitive sense to me, on the contrary, I find it confusing and counter-intuitive (sometimes). I believe in physics because the people who make magic boxes of light and sound that move fast and connect across vast distances tell me they did so via the knowledge they derived from physics. It's not how I would've guessed the universe would work, but who am I to argue with a blazing altar?
Judging by this standard I find many academic disciplines are severely wanting - there is a lot of chanting and waving of hands, but very little smoke. If I hear on the news that there's going to be an eclipse, I'll go out and look. If I hear on the news that eggs are bad for you, I'm going to roll my eyes.