Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by chiefalchemist on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @06:58AM
(#30853550)
Exactly! But meanwhile the narrative in the USA is "we're so benevolent for accepting the world's best & brightest." The USA gets stronger. The sources of that strength weaker. It's a broken idea.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by renewiltord on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @12:26PM
(#30857401)
If you take a top experimental particle physicist and put him in Dhaka you don’t get great experimental particle physics; you get a mediocre accountant with memories of particle physics.
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by rayiner on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @12:52PM
(#30857758)
Fazlur Kahn, the structural engineer and architect behind the Sears Tower, once went to accept some award in his home country of Bangladesh. Someone asked why he didn’t come back home. He responded: “I design skyscrapers. What would I do here?”
Which is true. At the same time, what’s been his contribution to Bangladesh? Nothing, aside from a bit of trivia I tell people when I show them around Chicago.
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by valarauko on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:09PM
(#30859532)
So what's the takeaway from the anecdote here? That Fazlur Khan should have returned to Bangladesh?
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by chiefalchemist on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @12:33PM
(#30857501)
Let me rephrase:
If you take one of Dhaka's best and brightest and remove him/her...Dhaka gets nothing.
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by valarauko on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:34PM
(#30859814)
I think the usual counter to this argument is that rather than being the best & brightest, he's a product of his time, place, and circumstances - if he were to remain in Dhaka he likely may not have been noteworthy. We really don't know one way or another.
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by chiefalchemist on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:51PM
(#30861268)
Noteworthy is relative. Aside from being able a person needs to have the "heart" to relocate to the USA. So yeah, she / he might professionally end up an accountant. But the heart to change things? That should not be discounted either.
Like it or not, there is a darkside to USA immigration policy, just because its been normalized doesn't mean it's not there.
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by valarauko on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @06:20PM
(#30861538)
I don't think anybody discounts it or hand waves brain drain away. My concern is that these notions might inform (well meaning) ideas of what immigration should look like - it feels overly paternalistic and minimizes the immigrant's desires and agency. Immigration is already an incredibly difficult and uphill task that's near impossible for the vast majority of people even with the means and desire to do so. However difficult you think it is, multiply by a factor of 10. So now should the process be even harder because of concerns about brain drain? For example, should American concerns about brain drain from the underdeveloped countries inform if people should be allowed to immigrate from there? Should immigration be open only to people from rich countries?
Re:America COMPETES Act of 2022 passed House and Senate
by renewiltord on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:44PM
(#30859931)
If you look at the guy who would be a top experimental particle physicist in the West and leave him in Dhaka you don't get great experimental particle physics; you get a mediocre accountant with dreams of particle physics.