News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by bryanlarsen on Friday October 07, 2011 @11:41AM (#3084418)
There's a lot of innovation in open source software: most University projects are all about doing new things, and a relatively large percentage of University projects are open source.

But what you're asking for is nonsensical. This list is the list of things that are preventing people from going "fully free". I'm not prevented from switching to free software because something that does not exist is not free software.

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by DanielStraight on Friday October 07, 2011 @11:48AM (#3084462)
Every piece of software we use today will eventually be obsolete anyway. Photoshop, Google Earth, even BIOSes will eventually look old-fashioned and quaint. If you (in the impersonal sense, not you personally) want to get converts, make the software that makes today's software obsolete. If you don't make it, someone else will, and when they do, your FOSS version will be obsolete as well.
Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by bryanlarsen on Friday October 07, 2011 @11:58AM (#3084531)
But that's one of the major benefits of free software. The software that makes today's software obsolete will be able to do everything that today's software can do, and more.

Sometimes that's through new paradigms, but more often that's through incremental evolution.

Have a great idea for a spreadsheet? To implement it competitively you'll spend 99% of your time reinventing Excel and 1% of your time on your great idea. Or you can add it to gnumeric.

More likely you'll release an Excel plug-in, but what do you do if Excel doesn't have the right API hooks?

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by DanielStraight on Friday October 07, 2011 @01:09PM (#3084878)
I do not think it is likely that the software that makes today's software obsolete will be able to do everything that today's software can do and more.

Adding more is only one way to innovate. You can also innovate by changing things or by taking things away, thus bringing what remains into sharper focus.

A car does not do everything a horse can do and more, but cars still made horses obsolete for transportation. Cars can't jump over obstacles or reproduce, but apparently these features weren't really that important.

An iPad can't even compile Hello World in C, but apparently that isn't that important to a lot of people.

Nick Cernis innovated in the "to-do" space not by doing everything other to-do systems could do but by replacing software with a pencil-and-paper system that serves some people better (see: http://todoodlist.com/).

A spreadsheet is a means to an ends. If you have a great idea for a spreadsheet, what you really have is a great idea for something people need a better way to do that you think could be implemented in a spreadsheet. Instead of reinventing Excel, you might come up with an alternate way to get to the same end.

The point is that innovation comes in many forms.

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by bct on Friday October 07, 2011 @11:53AM (#3084505)
Software is only obsoleted by some other software getting adopted in its place. How well adopted a piece of software is is only vaguely related to how innovative it is, how technically sound it is, etc.

You're reducing a complex problem too far.

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by rcfox on Friday October 07, 2011 @02:34PM (#3085265)
> you (in the impersonal sense, not you personally)

The word you're looking for is "one".

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by DanielStraight on Friday October 07, 2011 @02:37PM (#3085282)
Usually, I'd agree with you, but it reads really bad in this case:

If one wants to get converts, one should make the software that makes today's software obsolete. If one doesn't make it, someone else will, and when they do, one's FOSS version will be obsolete as well.

Re:High Priority Free Software Projects by gbhn on Friday October 07, 2011 @03:10PM (#3085412)
As a Chrome developer, I'm biased, but I think a lot of very important and innovative work is happening on the web platform, and virtually all of it is open source.